Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026.11.17 Work Session Packet 4141 Douglas Drive North • Crystal, Minnesota 55422-1696 Tel: (763) 531-1000 • Fax: (763) 531-1188 • www.crystalmn.gov Posted: Nov. 13, 2026 City Council Work Session Agenda Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026 | 6:30 p.m. Upper Community Room/Zoom Pursuant to due call and notice given in the manner prescribed by Section 3.01 of the City Charter, the Crystal City Council work session was held on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, at _____ p.m. electronically via Zoom and in the upper community room at city hall, 4141 Douglas Dr. N., Crystal, Minnesota. If the agenda items are not completed in time for the regular city council meeting at 7 p.m., the meeting will be continued and resumed immediately following the Economic Development Authority meeting. I. Attendance Council members Staff ____ Onesirosan ____ Bell ____ Budziszewski ____ Tierney ____ Cummings ____ Therres ____ Deshler ____ Elholm ____ Eidbo ____ Hubbard ____ Kamish ____ Kunde ____ Kiser ____ Struve ____ Sutter ____ Serres II. Agenda The purpose of the work session is to discuss the following agenda items: 1) Community Development quarterly update. 2) Council liaison reports.* 3) Constituent issues update.* 4) City manager update.* 5) New business.* 6) Council comments and announcements.* 7) Unified Development Code amendments. III. Adjournment The work session adjourned at ______ p.m. * Denotes no supporting information included in the packet Auxiliary aids are available upon request to individuals with disabilities by calling the city clerk at (763) 531-1145 at least 96 hours in advance. TTY users may call Minnesota Relay at 711 or 1-800-627-3529. Community Development Dept. 3Q 2026 Update November 17, 2026John Sutter Community Development Director (763) 531-1130 john.sutter@crystalmn.gov www.crystalmn.gov Who we are (seven full-time employees) Chandler Clay Building & Housing Inspector John Sutter Director Dan Olson City Planner Joe Tomasetti Building Official Jeni Taylor Building & Commercial Inspector Jason Zimmermann Code Enforcement Manager Ashton Amsler Code Enforcement Inspector What we do •Plan reviews and inspections for permits •Rental licensing and inspections (616 houses and 2,097 apartments) •Planning and zoning (Planning Commission) •Code enforcement, both residential neighborhoods and commercial property •Business and development inquiries •EDA activities and special projects 2026 3Q Highlights Lotus Pointe (6000 56th) -Foundation complete and framing underway Ember (7000 56th) -Foundation and plan review for phase 2 nearly complete 30% design of TIF-funded improvements near 7000 56th Ribbon cuttings at Five Guys and Inkakaw Decorative downtown lighting installed 39 new commercial code enforcement cases initiated Planning Commission items:•CUP for Verizon tower at 3200 Vera Cruz•Proposed UDC amendments Permits, Inspections and Code Enforcement Summary Revenue Summary 2024 thru Sep. 30 2025 thru Sep. 30 2026 thru Sep. 30 DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 1 OF 8 ____________________________________________________________________________________ FROM: Dan Olson, City Planner TO: Adam R. Bell, City Manager (for November 17 meeting) DATE: November 10, 2026 RE: Discuss proposed amendments to the Unified Development Code ____________________________________________________________________________________ A. BACKGROUND Staff is requesting that City Council discuss proposed amendments to the unified development code (UDC). The proposed amendments include policy changes on three issues, as well as corrections or clarifications, brought about by things we learned while administering the UDC. Attachments: A. Proposed ordinance amendments B. Areas C and D from 2040 Comprehensive Plan C. Current zoning map showing areas for UO-PD D. Building design requirements from other cities B. PLANNING COMMISSION COMMENTS At the October 12, 2026 Planning Commission meeting, the Commission provided comments on the proposed UDC amendments. The following is a summary of those comments, followed by staff response. 1. Policy changes. The Commission was supportive of the three proposed policy changes described in section C of this staff report, to add the UO-PD overlay district, increase densities in the R-1, R-2, and R-3 districts, and to include additional building design requirements. Staff response. Unless directed otherwise by City Council, staff will include exterior building material requirements such as found in West St. Paul, Richfield, and St. Louis Park in the proposed UDC amendments. COUNCIL STAFF REPORT Discuss UDC amendments DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 2 OF 8 2. Clarifications and corrections. The Commission was supportive of those proposed amendments described in section D of this staff report. Staff response. These amendments will be included in the proposed ordinance for the Commission’s public hearing. 3. Amendment requests from Commission member Sumnicht. Commission member Tony Sumnicht submitted three suggested amendments for Planning Commission review relating to the establishment of zoning requirements for data centers, plug-in solar panels, and reducing parking for smaller commercial developments. Staff response. Staff recommends the following for these proposed amendments. a. Data centers. The UDC does not have a principal use called “data centers”, and therefore that use would not be allowed (staff proposes to strengthen the UDC language with this amendment that makes it clear that if a use is not listed it is not allowed). If City Council desires to allow data centers, staff has added proposed amendment language for that use in attachment A (pages 11, 79, 87-88, 129) which includes the following: • A general definition in section 505. • Data centers would be allowed in the Industrial (I) and Airport (AP) districts with an approved conditional use permit (CUP). Smaller facilities would be allowed in the I and AP districts, while larger facilities would only be allowed in the AP district. • Use-specific standards to address site development standards, including limits on the size of the facility, noise, water and energy consumption. b. Plug-in solar panels. • Plug-in solar panels plug directly into a standard wall outlet and can be set on a patio or in a yard (and occasionally on a roof), while conventional solar panels are larger, permanently hardwired into the main electrical panel by professional installers, and are typically installed to be flush mounted on a roof. • Plug-in solar panels are far less expensive than conventional panels. • Neither the UDC, state building code, or state statute have specific requirements for plug-in panels. Staff is not aware of any municipalities that have specific requirements for plug-in solar panels. • Plug-ins that are not placed on a building, such as those set on a patio, would not require approval of a building permit and therefore would not be subject to zoning approval. • Staff recommended UDC amendments: ➢ Clarify that plug-in panels, not mounted on a building, are not subject to zoning requirements. ➢ Require building-mounted plug-in rooftop panels to either be flush mounted or have a height limit when oriented at maximum tilt. DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 3 OF 8 c. Reduce parking requirements for commercial development. • The amendment proposes to eliminate minimum required number of parking spaces for commercial development of 5,000 gross sq. ft. or less in the NC and C districts. • Staff recommended UDC amendments: ➢ Stand-alone commercial developments under 5,000 gross sq. ft. of building space in the NC and C districts have no minimum required number of parking spaces. ➢ Multi-tenant commercial developments in the NC and C in the NC and C districts have no minimum required number of parking spaces for the first 5,000 sq. ft. of total gross building floor area, but standard parking requirements apply once that threshold has been met. C. PROPOSED POLICY CHANGES Staff has identified the following three issues involving a change of policy that will require additional discussion. 1. Create new redevelopment overlay zoning district called Urban Option – Planned Development district (UO-PD). The UO-PD overlay district would provide those properties outside the town center area the opportunity to redevelop according to the urban standards required in the Town Center (TC) and Town Center – Planned Development (TC- PD) districts. The proposed UO-PD district roughly aligns to redevelopment areas C and D in the Comprehensive Plan (attachment B), plus additional properties as described below and shown in attachment C. The UO-PD district is an overlay district that property owners could opt into to create urban style development. The Council should provide input on whether the site development standards (such as building height, setbacks, and density, should be different than the town center area (see current town center requirements below). Site plan element TC requirement UO-PD requirement (if different from TC) Building height 5 stories or 60’, whichever is less Front setback Minimum: 1’ Maximum: 12’ Interior side setback None Rear setback Minimum: 5’ Corner side setback Minimum: 2’ Maximum: 12’ Buildings to be built up to corner Density TC: 25-80 units per acre TC-PD: 16-64 units per acre DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 4 OF 8 Principal uses TC: Primarily retail, personal services, eating establishments and multi-family residential TC-PD: Also religious institutions, schools, and specialized care facilities Minimum number of parking spaces TC nonresidential: None TC residential: 1 space per unit plus 1 space for each 10 units for visitor parking TC-PD: Standard number of parking spaces based on specific use, but applicant can request a reduction during rezoning process Minimum lot area, width and depth None Building street frontage Building should occupy 60-75% of the lot width Minimum green space 90% of the lot can be impervious surface Properties proposed to be included in the UO-PD overlay district (attachment C): 6401 – 42nd Ave. N. Hennepin County library 4141 Douglas Dr. N. City hall, police station & fire station 4174 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4168 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4162 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4156 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4150 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4142 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4134 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4100 Douglas Dr. N. (two lots) Ascension Church 4173 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4167 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4161 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4149 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4141 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4131 Colorado Ave. N. Single-family home 4121 Brunswick Ave. N. City of Crystal reservoir 3915 Adair Ave. N. Robbinsdale School District office (formerly FAIR school) 6125 – 41st Ave. N. City of Crystal public works DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 5 OF 8 6225 – 42nd Ave N. Access Veterinary Care 6209 - 42nd Ave. N Inka Dental 6129 – 42nd Ave. N. Two barber shops 6113 - 6121 42nd Ave. N. Keng’s Chow Mein, Panaderia restaurant 6105 – 42nd Ave. N. Elision Playhouse 6023 – 42nd Ave. N. Tumble Fresh Coin Laundry 6001 – 42nd Ave. N. Adair Liquor 4169 Adair Ave. N. Single-family home 4171 Adair Ave. N Single-family home 6000 – 42nd Ave. N. Big B’s Gas & Goods 4217 Adair Ave. N. Single-family home 6016 – 42nd Ave. N. Tobacco shop 6028 – 42nd Ave. N. Retail businesses 4222 Brunswick Ave. N. Single-family home 6122 – 42nd Ave. N. Brunswick United Methodist Church 4210 – 4300 Douglas Dr. N. Almsted’s Fresh Market 4308 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4320 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 4309 Colorado Ave. N. Two unit residential building 4321 Colorado Ave. N. Two unit residential building 6304 – 42nd Ave. N. B & R Transmission 5930 West Broadway Apartment buildings 5924 West Broadway Geneva Discount Furniture 5900 West Broadway Apartment buildings 3600 Douglas Dr. N. Wine Thief/Ale Jail 6203 – 36th Ave. N. Eight townhome units 3528-3550 Douglas Dr. N. Retail businesses with associated parking lot 3504-3518 Douglas Dr. N. Eight townhome units 3448 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3442 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3430 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3422 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3414 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3408 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3400 Douglas Dr. N. Storage building 3354 Douglas Dr. N. Vacant EDA lot 6213 – 34th Ave. N. Vacant EDA lot 6203 – 34th Ave. N. Single-family home 3342 Douglas Dr. N. (two lots) Single-family home 3320 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3300 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3246 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3212 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3200 Douglas Dr. N. Two unit residential building DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 6 OF 8 3201 -3255 Colorado Ave. N. Nine vacant residential lots on unimproved street 6101 – 6215 32nd Ave. N. 18 townhome units 3141 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3157 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3201 Douglas Dr. N. El Chino Auto Sales 3219 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3237 Douglas Dr. N. Three unit residential building 3255 Douglas Dr. N. Two unit residential building 3305 Douglas Dr. N. Single-family home 3317 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3335 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 3353 Douglas Dr. N. Realtor office 6307 – 34th Ave. N. Single-family home 3401-3417 Douglas Dr. N. Eight townhome units 6308 – 34th Ave. N. Vacant office building 3400 Edgewood Ave. N. Single-family home 3412-3418 Edgewood Ave. N. Two vacant residential lots 3421-3437 Douglas Dr. N. Eight townhome units 3443 Douglas Dr. N. Vacant EDA lot 3501 Douglas Dr. N. Suite Living Senior Care 3517 Douglas Dr. N. Vacant commercial lot 3537 Douglas Dr. N. Retail businesses with associated parking lot 6319 – 36th Ave. N. Single-family home 6327 – 36th Ave. N. Single-family home 2700 Douglas Dr. N. Lamplighter Square shopping center 6300- 6400 27th Ave. N. Sedona Hills apartments 2756 Douglas Dr. N. Office building 2701 Brunswick Ave. N. Apartment buildings 2900 Douglas Dr. N. Apartment building 2725 – 2761 Dougla Dr. N. Six townhome units 6600 – 27th Ave. N. Neill Elementary School 2801 Douglas Dr. N. LDS Church 4701 – 36th Ave. N. Thrift store 4725 – 36th Ave. N. Pinnacle Dermatology 2. Increase density in R-1, R-2 and R-3 districts (page 121). To promote opportunities for more housing, the densities in the three base residential districts are proposed to increase. 3. Adopt additional building design requirements. City council has expressed an interest in requiring additional exterior building requirements in the city’s redevelopment districts. Attachment D provides exterior building requirements for the cities of West St. Paul, Richfield, St. Louis Park, and Hopkins. These cities have a predominantly suburban development pattern that is slowly transitioning to an urban development pattern. DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 7 OF 8 However, Hopkins is unique in that it also has a substantial historic downtown and the Planning Commission consensus is that its design guidelines are not a good fit for Crystal. The Council is asked to provide a recommendation on whether additional design requirements should be adopted. D.CLARIFICATIONS AND CORRECTIONS The majority of proposed UDC amendments would not be policy changes, but instead clarifications and corrections to existing requirements. The following are the proposed amendments: 1.Construction site office (pages 10, 108). The amendment adds a definition and requirements for temporary offices for construction projects. 2.Signs. ➢(page 23). The city attorney recommends deleting the word “speech” since the city’s sign code is content-neutral. ➢Page 99). Clarifies sign requirements for home businesses. ➢(page 182). Amendment clarifies that signs for home businesses and garage and yard sales have different requirements than listed in this subsection related to placement of signs in the right-of-way. ➢(pages 183, 186). Amendment prohibits illuminated signs, including electronically or electrically controlled readerboards, that are near low density residential areas to be lit between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. A conflicting standard for the NC district is deleted. ➢(pages 185, 186, 187). Amendment ensures that the same terminology is used throughout the UDC for electronically or electrically controlled readerboards. ➢(page 187). Clarifies that frontage roads are defined as minor collector streets for the purpose of calculating sign size. ➢(page 189). Allows more than one sandwich board sign for multiple-tenant commercial buildings; clarifies in which zoning district wall signs are allowed. ➢(page 190). Since the state’s requirements for election signs can change, this amendment references the state statute for these regulations. 3.Planning Commission (pages 29-30). Removes repetition of requirements already found in chapter 3; replaces the environmental quality commission with the sustainability commission. 4.Site plan amendments (page 39). Clarifies what defines an amendment and increases the threshold at which the amendment can be approved administratively by city staff. 5.Renaming of two zoning district classification (examples on pages 47 and 49). While approving the Town Center Vision Plan (TCVP), City Council discussed renaming the Town Center Base (TC) district to Downtown District and the Town Center-Planned Development (TC-PD) overlay district to Downtown Edge (DE) overlay district. These changes are proposed through the UDC but shown as examples on pages 47 and 49. 6.Remove height limit in Town Center (TC) district (pages 54, 122). This amendment proposes to remove the height limit for buildings in the TC district. To prevent negative impacts on residential properties, a specific standard is proposed for shadow effects (see item #13 below). DISCUSS UDC AMENDMENTS PAGE 8 OF 8 7.Unlisted uses (pages 77, 96-97, and 107). This amendment clarifies that if a principal, accessory or temporary use is not listed in the use tables, then that use is not allowed. An applicant may apply for a UDC text amendment to add the use. 8.Retail uses in the TC district (page 85). Establishes a process for requesting additional square footage in the TC district and allows for a limited amount of storage space. 9.Locational requirements for auto-oriented uses (pages 85-86). Clarifies locational requirements for vehicle sales and repair. 10.Firewood cribs (page 96). Clarifies requirements for firewood cribs. 11.Architectural requirements for commercial storage buildings (page 103). Establishes exterior material requirements for this type of detached building that are the same requirements for other detached buildings. 12.Noncommercial greenhouses (page 104, 126). Allows greenhouses on single and two- family properties in the same locations as other detached buildings. 13.Outdoor dining (page 109). For clarification purposes, the amendment is to use the same terms for outdoor dining used in other sections of the UDC. 14.Shadow effects (pages 115-116). Establishes a standard and requirements for principal building shadows that may impact adjacent residential uses. 15.Side setback for attached decks (page 124). Increases the side setback for attached decks from 3’ to 5’, so that the home and deck have the same requirement. 16.Height limits for NC district (page 128). This amendment provides a height limit for accessory buildings in the NC district, similar to what is found in other districts. 17.Blank walls for airplane hangars (page 129). The amendment allows airplane hangars to have blank walls. 18.Fence height for corner residential lots (pages 130-131). Provides a property owner height options for fences in the front and corner side yard but ensures that fences in front of the home’s entry will not exceed 4.5’ in height. 19.Current vehicle registration for single and two family dwellings (page 145). City council members have expressed interest in restoring the requirement that vehicles parked outside on single and two family properties have current registration (it is already required on other types of properties). 20.Driveways (page 153, 155). This amendment provides specific standards for auxiliary parking space tapers in the right-of-way and for water curb stops in driveways (requested by the city engineer). E.REQUESTED ACTION City Council to discuss and provide comments on the proposed UDC amendments. The following is the proposed schedule for considering the proposed UDC amendments: January 11 Planning Commission public hearing January 19 Council considers first reading of ordinance February 2 Council considers second reading and adoption February 11 Summary of ordinance published March 13 Effective date of ordinance 10 CR225-464-620540.v15 Subd. 33. Cannabis Retailer Business. “Cannabis Retailer Business” means a cannabis business that is a cannabis retailer, the retail portion of a cannabis mezzobusiness with a retail operations endorsement, or the retail portion of a cannabis microbusiness with a retail operations endorsement, a cannabis delivery service license, a cannabis business license with a delivery service endorsement, as those terms are defined in Minnesota Statutes, section 342.01 and applicable Minnesota administrative rules. Subd. 34. Canopy. “Canopy” means a roof-like cover, often made of fabric, plastic, metal, or glass on a support, which is affixed to a building and provides shelter over a doorway. Subd. 35. Carport. “Carport” means an accessory structure used generally for covering vehicles which is open on at least two sides. It may be attached to the home or be freestanding. If the structure is not open on at least two sides, it is considered a garage and shall comply with all requirements in this UDC for garages. Subd. 36. Cemeteries. “Cemeteries” means land used or dedicated to the burial of the dead, including mausoleums, necessary-related sales, and maintenance facilities. A funeral home may be included when operated within the boundary of such cemetery. Subd. 37. City. “City” means the City of Crystal, unless otherwise noted. Subd. 38. Club or lodge. “Club or lodge” means buildings or facilities owned or operated by a corporation, association, or persons for a social, educational, or recreational purpose; but not those which are primarily for profit or which render a service that is customarily carried on as a business. Subd. 39. Commercial truck storage or parking. “Commercial truck storage or parking” means a parking lot used for the storage or temporary parking of commercial vehicles in excess of three quarter (3/4) ton capacity. Subd. 40. Commercial storage building. “Commercial storage building” means a detached accessory building that is over 200 square feet in size and used primarily for storage for a commercial business. For the purposes of this UDC, commercial storage buildings are not synonymous with self-storage facilities. Subd. 41. Comprehensive plan. “Comprehensive plan” means the formally adopted comprehensive development plan of the city, composed of maps, charts, diagrams, and text describing the recommended policies and programs to guide the city’s future development and redevelopment. Subd. ___. Construction site office. “Construction site office” means a temporary structure, such as a travel trailer, used as an office in conjunction with an active construction project and for no other purpose. Subd. 42. Control measure. “Control measure” means a practice or combination of practices to control erosion and attendant pollution. Subd. 43. Critical facilities. “Critical facilities” means facilities necessary to a community’s public health and safety, those that store or produce highly volatile, toxic or water-reactive materials, and those that house occupants that may be insufficiently mobile to avoid loss of life or injury. Examples of critical facilities include schools, daycare facilities, nursing homes, fire and police stations, wastewater treatment facilities, public electric utilities, water plants, fuel storage facilities, and waste handling and storage facilities. Subd. 44. Curb cut. “Curb cut” has the meaning given it in the Crystal city code, chapter VIII. Attachment A 11 CR225-464-620540.v15 Subd. ____. Data center. “Data center” means a facility whose primary function is to house computers and/or equipment for the purpose of collection, processing, storage or retrieval of data. Subd. 45 Day care facilities, Adult. “Day care facilities, Adult” means a facility providing care for the elderly or functionally-impaired adults in a protective setting for a portion of the day. For day care facilities for children, see “Day care facilities, in-home”, Day care, group family facilities” and “Schools, nursery or preschool”. Subd. 46. Day care facilities, in-home. “Day care facilities, in-home” means a day care facility under rules and statutes of the State of Minnesota serving and providing care to 12 or fewer children. Subd. 47 Day care, group family facilities. “Day care, group family facilities” means a facility licensed under Minnesota Rules, parts 9502.0315 to 9502.0445 and which serves 14 or fewer children. Subd. 48. Deck, detached. “Deck, detached” means a freestanding deck which does not utilize the exterior wall of the principal structure for support. Subd. 49. Detention facility. “Detention facility” means a permanent natural or man-made structure, including wetlands, for the temporary storage of runoff which contains a permanent pool of stormwater. Subd. 50. Development. “Development” means any manmade change to improved or unimproved real estate, including buildings or other structures, dredging, filling, grading, paving, excavation, or drilling operations, or storage of equipment or materials. Subd. 51. Driveway. “Driveway” has the meaning given it in the Crystal city code, chapter VIII. Subd. 52. Driveway approach. “Driveway approach” has the meaning given it in the Crystal city code, chapter VIII. Subd. 53. Drive-through establishment. “Drive-through establishment” means any portion of a building, structure or property from which business is transacted, or is capable of being transacted, directly with customers located in a motor vehicle. Subd. 54. Dry cleaning plant. “Dry cleaning plant” means a building, portion of a building, or premises used for cleaning fabrics, textiles, or wearing apparel by immersion or agitation, or by immersions only, in volatile solvents including solvents of the petroleum distillate type, and/or the chlorinated hydrocarbon type, and the processes incidental thereto. Subd. 55. Dwelling. “Dwelling” means a building or portion thereof used exclusively for residential purposes, forming a habitable unit for one family. Garages, tents, and accessory structures shall not be considered dwellings and shall at no time be used as a dwelling, either temporarily or permanently. Tents may be used for recreational purposes. Subd. 56. Dwelling, multiple family. “Dwelling, multiple family” means a building designed with three or more dwellings exclusively for occupancy by three or more families living independently of each other. Subd. 57. Dwelling, one-family attached. “Dwelling, one-family attached” means a building, such as townhouses or row houses, containing dwellings in which: (a)Each dwelling is located on its own parcel; (b)Each dwelling is attached to another by party walls without openings; and 23 CR225-464-620540.v15 (o) Nonconforming sign. “Nonconforming sign” means any sign and its support structure lawfully erected prior to the effective date of this UDC which fails to conform to the requirements of this UDC. A sign which was erected in accordance with a variance granted prior to the adoption of this UDC and which does not comply with this UDC shall be deemed to be a legal nonconforming sign. A sign which was unlawfully erected shall be deemed to be an illegal sign. (p) Off-premise sign. “Off-premise sign” means a commercial speech sign which directs the attention of the public to a business, activity conducted, or product sold or offered at a location not located on the same premises where such business sign is located. For the purposes of this UDC: (1) A freestanding, monument or pylon sign shared by adjacent property owners shall not be considered an off-premise sign. (2) Easements and other appurtenances shall be considered to be outside such platted parcel of land and any sign located or proposed to be located in an easement or other appurtenance shall be considered an off-premise sign. (q) On-premise sign. “On-premise sign” means a sign that pertains to the use of the premises or the property on which it is located. (r) Pole sign. “Pole sign” means a sign which has the same meaning as pylon sign (see definition). (s) Portable sign. “Portable sign” means any sign which is manifestly designed to be transported, including by trailer or on its own wheels, even though the wheels of such sign may be removed and the remaining chassis or support is converted to another sign or attached temporarily or permanently to the ground since this characteristic is based on the design of such a sign. (t) Projecting sign. “Projecting sign” means any sign which is affixed to a building or wall in such a manner that its leading edge extends more than 15 inches beyond the surface of such building or wall face. A projecting sign is also a sign located above or below a canopy or marquee. (u) Pylon sign. “Pylon sign” means any freestanding sign which has its supportive structure(s) anchored in the ground and which has a sign face elevated above ground level by pole(s) or beam(s) and with the area below the sign face open. (v) Roof sign. “Roof sign” means any sign erected and constructed wholly on and above the roof of a building, supported by the roof structure, and extending vertically above the highest portion of the roof. (w) Rotating sign. “Rotating sign” means a sign or portion of a sign which turns about on an axis. (x) Sandwich board sign. “Sandwich board sign” means a moveable sign not attached to the ground and constructed in such as manner as for form an “A” or a tent-like shape, hinged or not at the top, each angular face held at an approximate distance by a supporting member. (y) Shimmering sign. “Shimmering sign” means a sign which reflects an oscillating sometimes distorted visual image. (z) Small sign. “Small sign” means a single sign six square feet or less in size. 29 CR225-464-620540.v15 Section 510 Administration 510.01. Applicability. Subd. 1. Procedures. All land use and development permit applications, except building permits, shall be governed by the procedures contained in this section. Subd. 2. Procedural review processes. There are three different levels of procedural reviews for applications submitted to the city. These three types of review procedures are described in the Crystal city code, subsection 510.11. This UDC further identifies which procedural review shall be necessary based upon each type of application. To the extent that any application process does not outline a procedural review, the zoning administrator shall determine the appropriate level of review. Subd. 3. Specific review processes. Specific procedures and decision criteria for each type of development review application are contained in the Crystal city code, subsection 510.13. Subd. 4. Appeals of administrative decisions. Appeals of any order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative officer in the enforcement of the UDC may be brought as provided in the Crystal city code, subsection 510.35. Subd. 5. Appeals of final decisions. The decisions of the city council under this UDC are final, except that any person aggrieved by a final decision of the city council may appeal the decision to district court as provided in Minnesota Statutes, section 462.361. In order to be timely, any such appeal shall be filed with the district court within 30 days of the date of the decision. 510.03. Planning commission. Subd. 1. Established. The planning commission is hereby established for the city. The planning commission is designated as the planning agency of the city in accordance with Minnesota Statutes, section 462.354. Subd. 2. Purpose. The purpose of the planning commission is to assist the city council in all matters relating to zoning and development or redevelopment of properties within Crystal. The planning commission’s role is advisory in nature. Subd. 3. Duties. The planning commission has those powers and duties assigned to it by Minnesota Statutes, sections 462.351 to 462.364, (the Municipal Planning Act) and as further provided under this UDC. Subd.4. Members. The planning commission shall be made up of nine members. There shall be at least two planning commission members from each of the four city wards. The remaining planning commission member shall be appointed on an at-large basis. Subd. 5. Qualifications. Planning commission members must be residents of the city and be at least fifteen years old. Qualifications for planning commission members are found in the Crystal city code, subsection 305.13. Subd. 6. Removal. Planning commission members serve at the pleasure of the city council and may be removed from the commission, with or without cause, upon a majority vote of the city council.Requirements for removal of planning commission members are found in the Crystal city code, subsection 305.13. 30 CR225-464-620540.v15 Subd. 7. Terms. Planning commission members shall be appointed to three-year terms. There are no term limits. To help ensure continuity in the planning commission’s work, the terms shall be staggered. As such, terms for the first nine planning commission members prescribed by this UDC shall expire as follows: (a) Four terms shall expire on December 31, 2017. (b) Three terms shall expire on December 31, 2018. (c) Two terms shall expire on December 31, 2019. Subd. 8. Other commissions. While serving on the planning commission, planning commission members may not also concurrently serve on the city’s parks and recreation commission or environmental quality sustainability commission. Subd. 9. Compensation. Planning commission members shall serve without compensation, but may be reimbursed for actual and necessary expenses if funds for that purpose are identified in the adopted city budget. Subd. 10. Liaison. The planning commission shall have both a city council liaison and a staff liaison. The city council liaison shall be assigned by the mayor. The staff liaison shall be assigned by the city manager. The commission may also have a staff secretary who is responsible for taking and preparing minutes during planning commission meetings. Subd. 11. Operations. The planning commission shall conduct itself in accordance with this UDC, the Crystal city code, section 305, the planning commission’s bylaws, and all other applicable laws and ordinances. 510.05. Board of appeals and adjustments. Subd. 1. Board of appeals and adjustments. Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 462.354, the city of Crystal board of appeals and adjustments is hereby established for the city. The city’s planning commission shall serve as the board of appeals and adjustments for the city. Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 462.354, subdivision 2, the decisions of the board of appeals and adjustments are advisory to the city council, which will make all final decisions. The Board shall operate under the same requirements as the planning commission in the Crystal city code, subsection 510.03. Subd. 2. Duties of the board. The board of appeals and adjustments shall have the following duties: (a) The board of appeals and adjustments hears and makes recommendations with respect to appeals from any order, decision, or determination made by an administrative officer in the enforcement of this UDC. (b) The board of appeals and adjustments hears requests for variances from literal provisions of this UDC in accordance with the provisions of Minnesota Statutes, section 462.357. (c) The board of appeals and adjustments hears appeals from the denial of a building permit for structures within the limits of a mapped street pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 462.359. 510.07. Zoning administrator. Subd. 1. Appointment. The city manager shall appoint a zoning administrator to administer and enforce this UDC. 39 CR225-464-620540.v15 (4) Replacement of a multiple family dwelling or nonresidential building on the same footprint and with the same height with no other site changes requested. (5) Airport facilities. (b) Site plans for the following construction requires approval through a Type 2 review procedure as established in this UDC: (1) New multiple-family dwellings of three units or more; (2) New nonresidential structures; (3) Additions to multiple-family dwellings or nonresidential structures of greater than 50 percent of the building footprint; (4) New parking ramps or structures. (c) Approval criteria. No site plan review application shall be approved unless it meets the following criteria: (1) It fully complies with all applicable requirements of this UDC; (2) It adequately protects residential uses from the potential adverse effects of a non-residential use; (3) It is consistent with the use and character of surrounding properties; and (4) It provides safe conditions for pedestrians or motorists and prevents the dangerous arrangement of pedestrian and vehicular ways. (d) Amendments to approved site plans approved through a Type 2 procedure. (1) After a site plan has been approved through a Type 2 procedure, the applicant may request approval of adjustments or rearrangements of buildings in the course of carrying out the plan. If the amendment involves increases or decreases changes to of 10 percent or less of the original floor area, not to exceed 500 1,000 square feet, the zoning administrator may approve the amendment after a Type 1 review procedure. Such amendment shall be in full compliance with the requirements of this UDC. If the amendment involves changes increases or decreases greater than 10 percent of the original floor area or exceeds 500 1,000 square feet, the amendment will be subject to a Type 2 review procedure. (2) The zoning administrator may also review and approve adjustments or rearrangements of items other than buildings, such as drives, parking areas, recreation areas, entrances, heights, yards, signage, landscaping, exterior lighting, surface water management plans, or similar modifications subject to a Type 1 review procedure. Such amendment shall be in full compliance with the requirements of this UDC. (e) Effect of city council decision of site plans approved through a Type 2 procedure. (1) Site plan approval shall expire one year from the date of approval unless the applicant has been issued a building permit for the work. Site plan approval shall also expire two years from the date of approval unless the work is complete and the building permit is finaled and closed. 47 CR225-464-620540.v15 (a) A request to rezone a property to Town CenterDowntown Edge Planned Development (TCDE- PD) shall only be allowed for those properties identified on the official zoning map as located within the TCDE-PD overlay district. When a property has been rezoned to TCDE-PD, there shall be no underlying zoning district classification. Subd. 2. Effect of city council decision. (a) If a site plan has been approved as part of the rezoning, the approval of a rezoning to a PD overlay district shall expire one year from the date of approval unless the applicant has been issued a building permit for the work. Site plan approval shall also expire two years after the date of approval unless the work is complete and the building permit is finaled and closed. (b) The applicant may request an extension of the expiration date in writing to the zoning administrator. The city council may approve one extension of not more than one year. Such written request shall include the following: (1) An explanation of what, if any, good faith efforts have been made to complete the site plan process; and (2) The anticipated completion date. (c) If the rezoning to a PD expires and the applicant has not received approval of an extension, the city council may rezone the property to the original zoning classification at the time of the PD application or to a zoning classification consistent with the comprehensive plan designation for the property. (d) A rezoning to a PD overlay district may continue in operation, regardless of ownership or ownership changes, provided the use meets all the standards and conditions of approval. 510.33. Variance. Subd. 1. Applicability. A variance is a modification or variation of the provisions of this UDC as applied to a specific piece of property. Pursuant to the procedures provided in Minnesota Statutes, section 462.357, use variances are prohibited. Subd. 2. Approval procedure. Variance applications shall be submitted, in writing, to the zoning administrator and are subject to a Type 2 review procedure. Subd. 3. Approval criteria. (a) Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 462.357, subdivision 6, the board of adjustments and appeals may only grant approval of variances where practical difficulties exist as to strict compliance with this UDC and each of the following criteria are satisfied: (1) The variance is in harmony with the general purposes and intent of this UDC; (2) The variance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; (3) The property owner proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted by this UDC; (4) The plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to the property not created by the landowner; and 49 CR225-464-620540.v15 Section 515 Zoning Districts and Use Regulation 515.01. Official zoning map. The official zoning map together with all materials attached thereto is hereby adopted by reference and declared to be a part of this section. The official zoning map shall be on file with the city clerk. 515.03. Establishment of zoning districts. (a) Established. The zoning classifications and zoning districts specified in Table 2 are hereby established within the city to carry out the purposes of this UDC. Table 2: Zoning Districts Abbreviation District Name BASE ZONING DISTRICTS R1 Low Density Residential District R2 Medium Density Residential District R3 High Density Residential District NC Neighborhood Commercial District C Commercial District TCD Town Center CoreDowntown District I Industrial District AP Airport District OVERLAY ZONING DISTRICTS FP Floodplain Overlay District SL Shoreland Overlay District PD Planned Development Overlay District DE-PD Downtown Edge Planned Development Overlay District UO-PD Urban Option Planned Development Overlay District (b) Relationship of overlay districts to base districts. (1) Where land is classified into an overlay zoning district, the regulations governing development in the overlay district shall apply in addition to the regulations governing the underlying base district, unless otherwise noted. In the event of a conflict between the standards of the overlay district and the base district, the standards governing the overlay district shall control. (2) In some instances land may be classified into multiple overlay districts. In the event of a conflict between the standards of the multiple overlay districts, the most restrictive standards shall apply. (c) Zoning district boundaries. 54 CR225-464-620540.v15 (2) Building height. Principal buildings do not have maximum height requirements but are subject to the following height requirements, in addition to those requirements found in the the Crystal city code subsection 520.01, subd. 5: Maximum building height requirements are shown in Crystal city code, subsection 520.03. (i) The following are additional height requirements. (ai) Story height. Stories above the ground floor are limited to 12 feet in height. Stories are measured from finished floor to finished ceiling. (bii) Ground floor height. If the ground floor has a non-residential use, the ground floor height shall be no less than 12 feet in height, but not more than 20 feet. Ground floor height above 20 feet counts as an additional story. (iii) Views. The building will not have significant negative impacts to the views of Becker Park by neighboring properties. (civ) Shadow effects study The applicant shall submit a shadow effects study to determine any negative shadow impacts to residential uses within 300 percent of the building height. If negative impacts are determined, the city may require design techniques to mitigate the impacts, such as reducing the height of the building, relocating or reorienting the building within the site, reducing building mass, or stepping-back a portion of the building. (dv) Proximity to Crystal Airport. Buildings shall comply with Crystal city code, subsection 520.01, subdivision 5(c) for construction near the Crystal Airport. (ii) Exceed height limitations. The city may, in its discretion, allow buildings to be constructed to a height of eight stories or 100 feet, whichever is less, upon consideration of the following factors. (a) Shadow effects. Shadow effects from the taller building will not have significant negative impacts on neighboring properties. A shadow effects study may be required by the city to document these impacts. (b) Building massing. The dimensions of the taller building are not disproportionately larger than neighboring buildings. (c) Views. The taller building will not have significant negative impacts to the views of Becker Park by neighboring properties. (3) Building facades. Building facades shall meet the following requirements. (i) Building articulation. Buildings exceeding 50 feet in width along a street shall incorporate articulation in street-facing facades to break down the scale of large buildings and create visual interest. Techniques to incorporate articulation include stepping back or extending forward a portion of the façade, using different textures or contrasting but compatible materials, dividing the building into storefronts with separate display windows and entrances, use of awnings, balconies, or similar ornamental features, or varying the roofline to reinforce the articulation of the primary façade (see Figure 8). 77 CR225-464-620540.v15 amount of activity, the type of customers or residents, how goods or services are sold or delivered, and site conditions. (2) Use types. The use categories are divided into specific use types. The use types identify the specific uses that are considered to fall within characteristics identified in the broader use category. For example, one-family or two-family are some of the specific use types that fall under the “household living” use category. (b) Symbols in table. The symbols used in Table 3 are defined as follows: (1) Permitted uses (P). A “P” in a cell indicates that a use type is allowed by-right in the respective zoning district subject to compliance with the use-specific standards set forth in the final “use-specific standards” column of Table 3. Permitted uses are subject to all other applicable standards of this UDC; (2) Conditional uses (C). A “C” in a cell indicates that a use type is allowed as a conditional use in the respective zoning district subject to compliance with the use-specific standards set forth in the final “use-specific standards” column of Table 3 and approval of a conditional use permit in accordance with the Crystal city code, subsection 510.19. Conditional uses are subject to all other applicable standards of this UDC. (3) Prohibited uses (--). A cell with a “--" indicates that the listed use type is prohibited in the respective zoning district. (4) Use-specific standards. The “use-specific standards” column of Table 3 cross-reference standards that are specific to an individual use type and are applicable to that use in all districts unless otherwise stated in the use-specific standards. (5) Unlisted uses. If an application is submitted for a use that is not listed in Table 3, the use is not permitted. The applicant may submit an application for an amendment to the text of the UDC according to the requirements of the Crystal city code subsection 510.29. zoning administrator is authorized to classify the new or unlisted use, with consultation from appropriate city departments, into an existing use type that most closely fits the new or unlisted use. If no similar use determination can be made, the zoning administrator shall refer the use to the planning commission, who may initiate an amendment to the text of this UDC to clarify where and how the use should be permitted. Table 3: Permitted Principal Uses Use Category and Use Type P = Permitted Use C = Conditional Use - = Not Permitted Base Zoning Districts Use-Specific Standards in Section: R-1 R-2 R-3 NC C TC I AP Residential Use Category Bed and Breakfast Establishments C C C C - - - - 515.19, subdivision 2 (a) Dwellings, Multiple Family - P P _ - P - - 515.19, subdivision 2 (b) 79 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 3: Permitted Principal Uses Use Category and Use Type P = Permitted Use C = Conditional Use - = Not Permitted Base Zoning Districts Use-Specific Standards in Section: R-1 R-2 R-3 NC C TC I AP Offices, Professional - P P P P P 515.19, subdivision 4 (g) Off-Sale Liquor Store - - - - P P P - 1200 & 515.19, subdivision (h) Parking Ramps or Structures - - - - P P P P 515.19, subdivision 4 (i) Personal Services - - - P P P P - 515.19, subdivision 4 (j) Principal Cannabis Business - - - - - - C - 515.19, subdivision 4 (k) Restaurants or Eating Establishments - - - P P P P - Retail Establishments - - - P P P P - 515.19, subdivision 4 (l) Theater, Indoor - - - C P P - - Tobacco Shop - - _ P P P - 1105 & 515.19, subdivision 4 (m) Vehicle Repair - - - - C - P - 515.19, subdivision 4 (n) Vehicle, Boat or Recreational Sales or Rental - - - - P - P - 515.19, subdivision 4 (o) Vehicle Fuel Sales - - - - P - - - 515.19, subdivision 4 (p) Vehicle Wash or Detailing - - - - C - C - 515.19, subdivision 4 (q) Industrial, Manufacturing, Research and Wholesale Use Category Building Materials Sales - - - - - - P - Bulk Storage of Liquids - - - - P - P P 515.19, subdivision 5 (a) Cannabis or hemp industrial business - - - - _ - C - 515.19, subdivision 5 (b) Data centers - - - - - - C C 515.19, subdivision 5 (c) Industrial Uses (Indoors) - - - - - - P - Industrial Or Commercial Uses with Outdoor Storage of Parts, Products, or Fuels - - - - - - P - 515.19, subdivision 5 (cd) Self Storage Facilities - - - - - - P - 85 CR225-464-620540.v15 county, then no cannabis retailer businesses are allowed in the city and the city shall not undertake process in the Minnesota Statutes, section 342.22 to register any such business. (l) Retail establishments. Retail establishments are subject to the following standards: (1) Repair is allowed for a retail establishment, but a conditional use permit is required if the repair is done outdoors. The applicant shall demonstrate that such outdoor repair will not negatively impact neighboring properties; (2) Within the TC district, retail space is limited to 15,000 gross square feet per floor, but . Additional additional square footage may be allowed with an approved conditional use permit., not to exceed a building footprint of 20,000 square feet No more than 5% of the gross floor area can be used for a storage (warehouse) use; (3) Within the NC and Commercial districts, retail establishments may have up to 50% of the gross floor area as storage or warehouse space; and (4) Within the Industrial district, retail establishments are limited to 50% of the gross floor area of the principal use. (5) Any retail establishment engaging in the sale at retail of any cannabis product, tobacco, or liquor at off-sale shall not be located within 500 feet of a school, public park, or residential treatment facility. The following apply for the purposes of this paragraph. (i) The distance between properties shall be measured from the closest points between the lot containing the business and the lot containing the identified use to which the buffer applies. (ii) The term “school” means a public or private facility that provides educational programs to ten or more people who are under the age of 21 in a classroom setting. The term includes, but is not limited to, any school operated by an independent school district or a charter school operating under Minnesota Statutes, chapter 124E. The term does not include the Robbinsdale Transition Center or similar adult education schools. (iii) The term “public park” means an open space, playground, athletic field, or other facility owned by the city, a school district, the county, or other public entity that is open to, and regularly used by, those under the age of 21. (iv) The term “residential treatment facility” means a facility providing mental health, alcohol, or drug treatment services established or operated in accordance with Minnesota Rules 2960, or Minnesota Statutes, chapters 245G or 260C. (m) Tobacco shops. Tobacco shops are subject to the following standards: (1) Shall comply with the standards imposed on retail establishments under subdivision 4 (l) of this subsection. (2) Shall not be located in any buffer zoned identified in subdivision 4 (l) (5) of this subsection. (n) Vehicle repair. Vehicle repair is subject to the following standards: (1) The property abuts at least one of the following street segments West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue North and the Canadian Pacific railroad;: 86 CR225-464-620540.v15 (i) West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue and the Canadian Pacific (CP) railroad; or (2) There is no outdoor parking or storage of vehicles that are to be worked on, are being worked on, or have been worked on. (o) Vehicle, boat, or recreational sales or rental. Vehicle, boat, or recreational sales or rental is subject to the following standards: (1) The property abuts at least one of the following street segments West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue North and the Canadian Pacific railroad:; (i) West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue and the Canadian Pacific (CP) railroad; or (2) There is no outdoor parking or storage of inoperable, unlicensed, abandoned or junk vehicles; and (3) No vehicle or equipment shall exceed 32 feet in length. (p) Vehicle fuel sales. Vehicle fuel sales are subject to the following standards: (1) The property abuts at least one of the following street segments: (i) West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue and the Canadian Pacific (CP) railroad; or (ii) 36th Avenue North between Highway 100 and a point 357 feet west of the centerline of Regent Avenue North. (2) Sufficient vehicular stacking space is provided on-site to minimize the blocking of traffic in the public right-of-way; and (3) If the property is adjacent to one or two residential family dwellings, the vehicle fuel sales businesses shall be closed between the hours of midnight and 5 a.m. (q) Vehicle wash or detailing. Vehicle wash or detailing establishments are subject to the following standards: (1) The property abuts at least one of the following street segments: (i) West Broadway between Corvallis Avenue and the Canadian Pacific (CP) railroad; or (ii) 36th Avenue North between Highway 100 and a point 357 feet west of the centerline of Regent Avenue North; (2) Sufficient vehicular stacking space is provided on-site to minimize the blocking of traffic in the public right-of-way. (3) A vehicle wash or detailing establishment shall comply with the use-specific standards for drive-through facilities in the Crystal city code, subsection 515.23, Subd. 2 (b). Subd. 5. Industrial, manufacturing, research and wholesale use category. 87 CR225-464-620540.v15 (a) Bulk storage of liquids. If the storage is within 300 feet of properties used for residential purposes, such storage shall not exceed 25,000 gallons. (b) Cannabis or hemp industrial businesses. Cannabis or hemp industrial businesses are subject to the following standards: (1) Businesses shall submit an odor mitigation plan that outlines all odor emitting aspects of the business and mitigations to be implemented to ensure odor is not readily detectable beyond the boundaries of the immediate site upon establishment of the business and for the full duration of the business. (2) Outdoor cultivation of cannabis is not permitted (c) Data centers. Data centers are subject to the following standards: (1) Data centers in both the I and AP districts are subject to the following standards: (i) Application. A conditional use permit application for a data center shall include the following: (a) A written technical study prepared by a registered professional engineer that describes the existing capacity of the water system, the proposed water system demands for the data center, and a description of the impact of the data center on private and municipal utilities. If required by city staff, a cost estimate shall be provided to mitigate the impacts of water usage by the center. Before the study is commenced, the applicant shall receive city staff approval of the professional engineer that they are requesting to use to complete the study. The cost of the study shall be borne by the applicant, and the results of the study shall be subject to review and approval by city staff for the conditional use permit to be approved. (b) Written statement that the data center will not exceed the capacity of the existing electrical grid or supply system. If grid or system improvements are necessary, the cost for the improvements will be borne by the owner of the data center and not by the local rate payers. (c) A sound mitigation plan that describes noise impacts from both the interior and exterior equipment and the plan to mitigate those impacts. Before the writing of the plan is commenced, the applicant shall receive city staff approval of the consultant that they are requesting to use to complete the plan. The cost of the plan development shall be borne by the applicant, and the plan shall be subject to review and approval by city staff for the conditional use permit to be approved. (d) Documentation that the private utility companies have been notified of the proposed conditional use permit application. (ii) Mechanical equipment. Mechanical equipment for a data center shall be located either in the building or on the building’s rooftop. If on a rooftop, the equipment shall meet the screening requirements of the Crystal city code, subsection 520.13. (iii) Residential buffer. The building and external equipment serving the data center shall be at least 100 feet from the property line of an abutting or adjacent residential use. (2) Data centers in the I district are subject to the following additional standard: 88 CR225-464-620540.v15 (i) The floor area for the data center shall be limited to no more than 100,000 gross square feet per property. (3) Data centers in the AP district are subject to the following additional standard: (i) The floor area for the data center shall be limited to no more than 200,000 gross square feet per property. (c) (d) Industrial or commercial uses with outdoor storage of parts, products, or fuels. Industrial uses with outdoor storage of parts, products or fuels are subject to the following standards: (1) The storage or parking area is hard surfaced, clearly designated on the site as being limited to the specific, approved area, and meets the relevant requirements as provided in the Crystal city code, subsection 520.15 for hard surface design; (2) The storage or parking area does not exceed 100% of the gross floor area of the principal building, 50% of the area of the property, or 10,000 square feet, whichever is less; (3) The storage or parking area is prohibited in the front or corner side yard; (4) The storage or parking area is subject to the screening requirements of the Crystal city code, subsection 520.13; and (5) The applicant must obtain zoning certificate approval for the storage or parking area. Subd. 6. Public facilities, telecommunications and utilities use category. (a) Public utility buildings. Equipment and materials are completely enclosed in a permanent building with no outside storage, unless in compliance with the screening requirements of this UDC. (b) Telecommunications towers. (1) Findings. The Federal Communications Act of 1934 as amended by the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (“the Act”) grants the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) exclusive jurisdiction over the regulation of the environmental effects of radio frequency emissions from telecommunications facilities and the regulation of radio signal interference among users of the radio frequency spectrum. By this subsection, the city intends to exercise the full scope of its authority under the Act and under state law regarding the regulation of towers and telecommunications facilities in the city. Consistent with the Act, the regulation of towers and telecommunications facilities in the city will not have the effect of prohibiting any person from providing wireless telecommunications services. (2) Purpose. The general purpose of this subsection is to regulate the placement, construction and modification of telecommunication towers and facilities in order to protect the health, safety and welfare of the public, while not unreasonably interfering with the development of the competitive wireless telecommunications marketplace in the city. Specifically, the purposes of this subsection are: (i) To regulate the location of telecommunication towers and facilities; (ii) To protect residential areas and land uses from potential adverse impacts of telecommunication towers and facilities; 96 CR225-464-620540.v15 Subd. 1. Purpose. This subsection authorizes accessory uses and structures that are incidental and customarily subordinate to principal uses. The intent of this subsection is to allow accessory uses while not creating adverse impacts on surrounding lands. Subd. 2. General provisions. (a) Table 4 lists the accessory uses allowed within all zoning districts except for the overlay zoning districts. Except for the TC-PD district which has separate requirements, the uses permitted in the overlay districts shall be controlled by the underlying base zoning district. (b) Small accessory uses such as arbors, benches, doghouses, play sets, garden decorations, pergolas, and firewood cribs (wood piles) are exempt from the provisions of this subsection, but cannot be located in public rights-of-way. Additional requirements for firewood cribs are located in the Crystal city code, subsection 605.13. (c) Tents, play houses, or similar structures shall not be used as temporary or permanent dwelling units, but may be used for recreational purposes. (d) Accessory structures shall only be constructed concurrent with or after the construction of the principal building on the same site. (e) Uses and structures that are accessory to a conditional principal use shall be permitted in accordance with this subsection, without requiring a conditional use permit amendment, unless specifically required as a condition of the conditional use permit approval. Subd. 3. Explanation of table of permitted uses. (a) Symbols in table. The symbols used in Table 4 are defined as follows: (1) Permitted uses (P). A “P” in a cell indicates that a use type or structure is allowed by-right in the respective zoning district subject to compliance with the use-specific standards set forth in the final “use-specific standards” column of Table 4. Permitted uses are subject to all other applicable standards of this UDC; (2) Conditional uses (C). A “C” in a cell indicates that a use type or structure is allowed as a conditional use in the respective zoning district subject to compliance with the use-specific standards set forth in the final “use-specific standards” column of Table 4 and approval of a conditional use permit in accordance with the Crystal city code, subsection 510.19. Conditional use permits are subject to all other applicable standards of this UDC; (3) Prohibited uses (-). A cell with a “-" indicates that the listed use type or structure is prohibited in the respective zoning district; (4) Use-specific standards. The “use-specific standards” column of Table 4 cross-reference standards that are specific to an individual use type or structure and are applicable to that use or structure in all districts unless otherwise stated in the use-specific standards; and (5) Unlisted uses. If an application is submitted for a use or structure that is not listed in Table 4, the use is not permitted. The applicant may submit an application for an amendment to the text of this UDC according to the requirements of the Crystal city code subsection 510.29. zoning administrator is authorized to classify the new or unlisted use or structure, with consultation from appropriate city departments, into an existing use or structure type that most closely fits the new or unlisted use. If no similar use determination can be made, 97 CR225-464-620540.v15 the zoning administrator shall refer the use to the planning commission, who may initiate an amendment to the text of this UDC to clarify where and how the use should be permitted. Table 4: Permitted Accessory Uses and Structures Use Category and Use Type P = Permitted Use C = Conditional Use - = Not Permitted Base Zoning Districts Zoning Certificate Required Use-Specific Standards in Subsection: R-1 R-2 R-3 NC C TC IAP Accessory Uses Assembly or gathering space - - - P P P P - No 515.23, subdivision 2 (a) Day Care Facilities, In home P P P - - P - - No Drive-through facilities - - - - C - - - Not Applicable 515.23, subdivision 2 (b) Home Businesses P P P - - P - - No 515.23, subdivision 2 (c) Keeping of Chickens P P - - - - - - No 910 Kennels, Commercial P - - - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 2 (d) Kennels, Multiple Animal P P P - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 2 (e) Retail sale of cannabis products, off-sale liquor, or tobacco products - - - - P P P - No See Note [4] Accessory Structures Accessibility ramps P P P P P P P P No 515.23, subdivision 3 (a) Accessory dwelling units P P - C - - - - Yes 515.23, subdivision 3(b) Amateur radio towers P P P - - - - P No 515.23, subdivision 3(c) Balconies - P P P - P - - No 515.23, subdivision 3 (d) Carports P P - - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 3(h) Clothesline poles P P - - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 3(e) Commercial storage buildings - - - - C - P P See Note [1] 515.23, subdivision 3(f) Fences and walls P P P P P P [2] P P No 520.09 Flagpoles P P P P P P P P No Fuel pumps, private use - - - - P - P P No 515.23, subdivision 3 (g) Garages, attached or detached P P P P P - P P No 515.23, subdivision 3(h) Gazebos P P P - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 3(i) Mechanical equipment P P P P P P P P 520.13 Micro dwelling units C C C C C - C - Not Applicable 515.23, subdivision 3 (j) Noncommercial greenhouses P P - - - - - - No 515.23, subdivision 3(k) Off-street parking and loading [3] P P P P P P P P Yes 520.15 Patios, decks, and porches P P P P P P - - No 515.23, subdivision 3 (l) Sheds P P P P P - P P No 515.23, subdivision 3(m) 100 CR225-464-620540.v15 (5) A home business may be located within the dwelling, an accessory building, or both, provided that the total area of the home business is not greater than 50% of the finished floor area of the dwelling; (6) Such home business shall not require internal or external alterations or involve construction features not customarily found in dwellings; (7) There shall be no exterior storage or display of equipment, goods or materials used in the home business; and (8) One sign, as allowed in Table 14 may be placed on the property, not to exceed six square feet in area., may be placed on the premises. The sign may identify the home business, resident name, address, website, and email address or phone number, but may contain no other information. The sign may not be illuminated and must be set back a minimum of ten feet from a property line abutting a public street. If the sign is freestanding, the total height may not exceed five feet. (d) Kennels, commercial. Commercial kennels are subject to the following standards: (1) In the R-1 zoning district, commercial kennels shall only be allowed at one-family dwellings, and the use of the commercial kennel is limited to raising, selling, boarding, breeding, and grooming of dogs or other animals; and (2) Commercial kennels shall adhere to the requirements for home businesses in this subsection. (e) Kennels, multiple animal. If a multiple animal kennel is operated as a home business, it shall adhere to the requirements for home businesses in this subsection. (f) Sale of cannabis products, off-sale liquor, and tobacco products. Any retail establishment that sells cannabis products, off-sale liquor, or tobacco products at retail as an accessory use to its principal use is subject to the following standards: (1) The sale of such products shall only be accessory to, and occur within, a retail establishment. If a retail establishment derives more than 50% of its gross revenue from the sale of any one of these products, such sales cannot be considered an accessory use and the retail establishment must obtain all permits or permissions required to sell the product as its principal use. (2) The retail establishment must possess such licenses as may be required to sell such products. (3) The sale of such products is only allowed if the lot containing the retail establishment is located outside the buffers identified in Crystal city code subsection 515.19, subdivision 4 (i) (5). (4) If the retail establishment is selling cannabis products, it must be registered with the city in accordance with Minnesota Statutes, section 342.22 and the procedures established by the city. Subd. 3. Accessory structures. 103 CR225-464-620540.v15 (5) The architectural style is compatible with the principal building and surrounding land uses. Commercial storage buildings in the commercial and industrial districts shall also comply with the following standards: Exterior building design and materials shall comply with the provisions as provided in the Crystal city code, subsection 520.05; and (i) The storage building shall not be constructed of the following materials: fabric, canvas, concrete block, unadorned prestressed concrete panels, plastic sheets, tarps, unfinished or corrugated metal, exposed plywood, particle board, or similar materials; and. (ii) Blank walls are prohibited. (6) The use will not conflict with the character of development intended for the zoning district. (g) Fuel pumps, private use. Private fuel pumps for use by commercial businesses are allowed, provided that the current business, or its successor business, only uses the fuel pumps for its vehicles and equipment and does not allow them to be used by the general public. For the purposes of this UDC, private fuel pumps do not include those fuel pumps in use by a vehicle fuel sales business as allowed in Table 3. (h) Garages and carports. Garages and carports are subject to the following standards: (1) Attached and detached garages are subject to the following standard: (i) Garages shall be accessed through a vehicular entrance door with an opening not less than seven feet wide and seven feet high. A garage shall be no less than nine feet wide and eighteen feet long, measured as the continuous clear space between the insides of the interior walls or wall framing if unfinished. (2) Attached and detached garages and carports are subject to the following standard: (i) Garages and carports shall have a floor constructed of poured concrete in accordance with standards approved by the city engineer and building official. (3) Detached garages and carports are subject to the following standards: (1) For one and two family dwellings, the cumulative area of all detached accessory buildings on the property shall not exceed the finished floor area of the residential portion of the principal building; (2) For multiple family dwellings, detached garages shall be designed to meet the minimum number of required parking spaces and required setbacks. To the extent practicable, garages shall be located to the side or rear of the building; and (3) Garages and carports shall not be constructed of the following materials: fabric, canvas, concrete block, cloth, plastic sheets, tarps, unfinished or corrugated metal, exposed plywood, particle board, or similar materials. (i) Gazebos. Gazebos are subject to the following standards: (1) The cumulative area of all detached accessory buildings on the property shall not exceed the finished floor area of the residential portion of the principal building; and 104 CR225-464-620540.v15 (2) Gazebos shall not be constructed of the following materials: fabric, canvas, concrete block, cloth, plastic sheets, tarps, unfinished or corrugated metal, exposed plywood, particle board, or similar materials. (j) Micro unit dwellings. Micro unit dwellings are subject to the following standards: (1) Each unit shall not exceed a gross floor area of 400 square feet; (2) Micro unit dwellings shall be included in the residential density calculation for the zoning district in which it is located; (3) Micro unit dwelling shall be constructed as to be compatible in composition, appearance, and durability with the exterior materials of the principal building of the religious institution; (4) The residents of each dwelling unit shall have access to water and electric utilities either by connecting the units to utilities serving the principal building of the religious institution or by providing residents access to permanent common kitchen facilities and common facilities for toilet, bathing, and laundry within the principal building. (5) An application for a conditional use permit shall contain a written plan approved by the religious institution’s governing board that outlines the information in Minnesota Statutes, section 327.30, subdivision 3 (b). (6) For any city-approved micro dwelling unit, the religious institution shall annually certify to the city that it has complied with the eligibility requirements for residents in Minnesota Statutes, section 327.30, subdivision 1. (k) Noncommercial greenhouses. Noncommercial greenhouses are subject to the following standards: (1) Shall be located in the rear yard; (2)(1) Shall be limited to one per property; and (3)(2) The cumulative area of all detached accessory buildings on the property shall not exceed the finished floor area of the residential portion of the principal building; and. (4)(3) Noncommercial greenhouses shall not be constructed of the following materials: fabric, canvass, concrete block, cloth, plastic sheets, tarps, unfinished or corrugated metal, exposed plywood, particle board, or similar materials. (l) Patios, decks and porches. Within the TC district, porches and decks are not permitted. (m) Sheds. Sheds are subject to the following standards: (1) The cumulative area of all detached accessory buildings on the property shall not exceed the finished floor area of the residential portion of the principal building; and (2) Sheds shall not be constructed of the following materials: fabric, canvas, concrete block, cloth, plastic sheets, tarps, unfinished or corrugated metal, exposed plywood, particle board, or similar materials. (n) Sidewalks. Sidewalks are subject to the following standards: 107 CR225-464-620540.v15 (d) Permit required. The “permit required” column defines if the proposed temporary use or structure requires approval of a zoning certificate or other permit; (e) Use-specific standards. The “use-specific standards” column of Table 5 cross-reference standards that are specific to an individual use type and are applicable to that use in all districts unless otherwise stated in the use-specific standards; and (f) Unlisted uses. If an application is submitted for a use that is not listed in Table 5, \the use is not permitted. The applicant may submit an application for an amendment to the text of this UDC according to the requirements of the Crystal city code subsection 510.29. zoning administrator is authorized to classify the new or unlisted use, with consultation from appropriate city departments, into an existing use type that most closely fits the new or unlisted use. If no similar use determination can be made, the zoning administrator shall refer the use to the planning commission, who may initiate an amendment to the text of this UDC to clarify where and how the use should be permitted. 108 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 5: Permitted Temporary Uses and Structures Use Category and Use Type P = Permitted Use - = Not Permitted Base Zoning Districts R-1 R-2 R-3 NC C TC I AP Allowable Duration (per site) Permit Required Use-Specific Standards in Section: Construction Dumpster P P P P P P P P No more than three consecutive months in any 12-month period See city code section 605 515.27, subdivision 2; 605 Construction site office Structure shall be removed within 15 days of the issuance of the certificate of occupancy No Garage/Yard Sales P P P - - - - - Maximum of three consecutive days, four times per calendar year per site No 515.27, subdivision 3 Outdoor dining [1] P P P P P P P P 270 days per site per calendar year Zoning Certificate (Type 1 Review) [2] 515.27, subdivision 4 Outdoor sales [1] - - - P P P P - 270 days per site per calendar year Zoning Certificate (Type 1 Review) 515.27, subdivision 5 Portable Storage Container P P P P P - P P 60 days per site per calendar year No 515.27, subdivision 6 Signs, Temporary P P P P P P P P See section 530 Sign Permit 530 Notes: 1. Outdoor seating for cafes or restaurants or outdoor sales areas for retail establishments that exceed the temporary use duration time limits would require a conditional use permit. 2. A zoning certificate is not required for a mobile food unit. 515.27. Use-specific standards for temporary uses and structures. Subd. 1. Purpose and applicability. (a) This subsection provides site planning and/or operating standards for certain land uses that are permitted in Table 5. 109 CR225-464-620540.v15 (b) The land uses and activities covered by this subsection shall comply with the applicable standards for the specific use in all districts unless otherwise specified, in addition to all other applicable provisions of this UDC. Subd. 2. Construction dumpsters. Construction dumpsters are subject to the following standards: (a) If the dumpster is located in the public right-of-way, the dumpster shall comply with the requirements of the Crystal city code, chapter VIII; and (b) If the dumpster is located on private property, the dumpster shall be located to the side or rear of the site, but away from principal buildings on adjacent properties, to the extent practicable. Subd. 3. Garage or yard sales. Garage or yard sales are subject to the following standards: (a) Hours of operation for the garage or yard sale are limited to between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m.; and (b) Garage or yard sale signs identifying the location and times of a sale may be placed on the property at which the sale is to be conducted or on the property of others with their consent. Such signs shall not exceed 4 square feet in area per side; shall not be placed on or attached to any public property or utility pole; shall not be placed within the sight triangle as required in the Crystal city code, chapter VIII; and must be removed within 24 hours of the time stated on such sign for the conclusion of the sale. Subd. 4. Outdoor dining. Outdoor dining is subject to the following standards: (a) Mobile food units. Mobile food units are subject to the requirements in the Crystal city code, chapter XIII; (b) Outdoor seating dining for cafes or restaurants or eating establishments. If a restaurant or eating establishment has Outdoor outdoor seating dining, that use for cafes and restaurants is subject to the following standards: (1) An outdoor dining area may be allowed accessory and incidental to a restaurant with indoor eating area on the same site provided that the outdoor eating area shall comply with the parking requirements in Table 11 of the Crystal city code, subsection 520.15; (2) Outdoor dining areas shall be designated on a site plan submitted for the zoning certificate application; (3) If no grade separation is provided between vehicular traffic and the outdoor dining area, permanent railings or fencing shall be provided around the dining area. If the outdoor dining area is adjacent to a sidewalk or other facility that is closed to vehicular traffic, no railing or fencing shall be required; (4) Umbrellas, or other protective elements, that shelter diners from the elements shall be secured so as not to create a hazard; (5) Enclosing an outdoor dining area either by a permanent roof or to expand the existing structure shall meet all the requirements of a building within the applicable zoning district; and (6) Within the TC and TC-PD districts, outdoor dining may encroach into setback areas or the public right-of-way, provided that the sidewalk remains clear to a width of five feet. 115 CR225-464-620540.v15 Figure 14: Illustration of typical setback locations for a one-family dwelling (a) Front setbacks. A front setback shall be measured at right angles from the nearest point on the public right-of-way at the front of the parcel to the nearest point of the wall of the structure, except as provided for in this subsection. (b) Side setbacks. The side setback shall be measured at right angles from the nearest point on the side property line of the parcel to the nearest point of the wall of the structure, establishing a setback line parallel to the side property line, which extends between the front and rear setbacks (see Figure 14). (c) Rear setbacks. The rear setback shall be measured at right angles from the nearest point on the rear property line to the nearest part of the structure, establishing a setback line parallel to the rear property line (see Figure 14). (d) Corner lots. The corner side setback shall be measured from the nearest point of the wall of the structure to the nearest point of the wall of the structure. (see Figure 14) Subd. 5. Height requirements and exceptions. (a) Standards. Each structure shall comply with the height requirements of the applicable zoning district, except: (1) As allowed in Table 6 when a building feature encroaches into a required height; and (2) The height of telecommunications facilities, including antennas, poles, towers, and necessary mechanical appurtenances, shall comply with the Crystal city code, subsection 515.19. (3) The following required standards are intended to preserve daylight and solar access for residential uses. (i) Prohibited shadows. New buildings shall not exceed a height that would cast shadows on existing residential uses at both 10:00 a.m. and 2:00 p.m. central standard time on December 21. 116 CR225-464-620540.v15 (ii) Shadow analysis. Any relevant development review application shall include a shadow analysis for a new building that may impact adjacent residential uses. The shadow analysis shall include a site plan showing the proposed building, surrounding residential uses, and the shadow cast by the proposed building(s) at both 10:15 a.m. and 2:15 p.m. on December 21. The shadow analysis shall take into account differences in topography and shall assume the following: Time on December 21 Solar Azimuth Shadow Length 10:15 a.m. Standard time 152.12 degrees 3.38 x building height 2:15 p.m. Standard time 199.76 degrees 3.48 x building height (b) Measurement of building height. The maximum allowable building height shall be measured in feet as the vertical distance from the average grade around the perimeter of a structure to (see Figure 15): (5) The deck line of a mansard roof; or (6) The highest point of a flat roof; or (7) The mean height between the eaves and highest point on gable, hip or gambrel roof. The location of average grade shall be determined by the zoning administrator and shall not be artificially raised to gain additional building height. Figure 15: Illustration of height measurement (c) FAA requirements. Height requirements shall meet the requirements of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). (1) Notice to the Federal Aviation Administration using FAA form 7460-1 is required prior to the following: 121 CR225-464-620540.v15 (a) Site development standards for principal buildings. Table 7 are the regulations for residential densities, setbacks, number of principal buildings, lot dimensions, building height, and green space for placing principal buildings in the city’s zoning districts. (b) Site development standards for accessory structures. Table 8 are the setback and height requirements for placing accessory structures in the city’s zoning districts. Table 7: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Principal Buildings R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP Permitted Residential Density Permitted Residential Density No more than 6 8 units per acre (gross) 6 to 16 20 units per acre (gross) 16 to 40 50 units per acre (gross) 16 to 40 units per acre (gross) Not Applicable 25 to 80 units per acre (gross) Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Minimum Building Setbacks [1] Front 30 feet 30 feet 30 feet 10 feet 10 feet 1 foot minimum 10 foot maximum 10 feet 200’ from resi- dential use Side 5 feet 10 feet 15 feet 10 feet 10 feet 0 foot minimum 10 feet 200’ from resi- dential use Rear 30 feet 30 feet 30 feet 10 feet 10 feet 5 foot minimum 10 feet 200’ from resi- dential use Corner Side 10 feet [2] 30 feet 30 feet 10 feet 10 feet 2 foot minimum 12 foot maximum 10 feet 200’ from resi- dential use Number of Principal Buildings Maximum number of principal buildings per property One One One One One Not Applicable One Not Appli- cable Minimum Lot Area One-family Detached Dwelling 6,000 SF 6,000 SF Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Two-Family Dwelling 10,000 SF 10,000 SF 10,000 SF Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Other Residential Uses Not Applicable 10,000 SF 20,000 SF 10,000 SF Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable 122 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 7: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Principal Buildings R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP Non- Residential Uses [3] Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 10,000 SF 20,000 SF Not Applicable 20,000 SF Not Appli- cable Minimum Lot Depth One-family Detached Dwelling 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Two-Family Dwelling 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Other Residential Uses Not Applicable 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Non- Residential Uses [3] 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet 120 feet Not Applicable 120 feet Not Appli- cable Minimum Lot Width One-family Detached Dwelling 50 feet 50 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Two-Family Dwelling 80 feet 80 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Other Residential Uses Not Applicable 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Non- Residential Uses [3] 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet 100 feet Not Applicable 100 feet Not Appli- cable Maximum Building Height One-family Detached Dwelling 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Two-Family Dwelling 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Other Residential Uses Not Applicable 3 stories or 40 feet, whichever is less 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is less 3 stories, or 40 feet, whichever is less Not Applicable 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is lessNot Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Non- Residential Uses [3] 2 stories or 32 feet, whichever is less 3 stories or 40 feet, whichever is less 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is less 3 stories, or 40 feet, whichever is less 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is less 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is lessNot Applicable 5 stories or 60 feet, whichever is less 3 stories or 40 feet, which- ever is less Minimum Green Space [4] 124 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 8: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Accessory Structures Accessory Structure Type R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP Amateur radio towers See note [1], below See note [1], below See note [1], below Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable See note [1], below Attached Decks and open porches Front: 30 feet Side: 3 5 feet Rear: 30 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 15 feet Rear: 30 feet Corner side: 30 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 15 feet Rear: 30 feet Corner side: 30 feet Front: 10 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 15 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Clothesline Poles Front: Not allowed Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: Not allowed Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Commercial Storage Buildings Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Not Applicable Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Detached decks Front: 30 feet Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 5 feet Rear: 5 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 5 feet Rear: 5 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 10 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 15 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 10 feet Corner side: 15 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable 126 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 8: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Accessory Structures Accessory Structure Type R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP Noncommercial greenhouses Front: Not Applicable 30, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: Not Applicable Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Patios Front: 30 feet Side: 1 foot Rear: 1 foot Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 1 foot Rear: 1 foot Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 5 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Front: 5 feet Side: 5 feet Rear: 15 feet Corner side: 5 feet Front: 30 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Sheds Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building [2] Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 10 feet Rear: 10 feet Corner side: 30 feet Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 10 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 30 feet Not Applicable Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the principal building Side: 3 feet Rear: 3 feet Corner side: 10 feet Front: 30 feet, but cannot be closer to the street than the princi-pal build-ing Side: 5 feet Rear: 5 feet Corner side: 10 feet Solar energy systems See note [5], below See note [5], below See note [5], below See note [5] below See note [5], below See note [5], below See note [5], below See note [5], below 128 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 8: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Accessory Structures Accessory Structure Type R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP Accessory dwelling units, detached 22 feet 22 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Appli- cable Amateur radio towers Tower not to exceed 75 feet Tower not to exceed 75 feet Tower not to exceed 75 feet Not Applicable Not Applicable Tower not to exceed 75 feet Tower not to exceed 75 feet Tower not to exceed 75 feet Commercial storage buildings Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 20 feet 20 feet 25 feet Detached accessory buildings [6] 15 feet 15 feet 15 feet 15 feet Not Applicable 15 feet 15 feet 15 feet Essential services (such as poles or towers) As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As determined by the city engineer As deter- mined by the city engineer Fences See subsection 520.09 See subsection 520.09 See subsection 520.09 See subsection 520.09 Not Applicable See subsection 520.09 See subsection 520.09 See sub- section 520.09 Flagpoles 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet 25 feet Satellite dishes Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Not to exceed 4 feet above the roof Solar energy systems Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Freestanding: 20 feet when oriented at maximum tilt Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Freestanding: 20 feet when oriented at maximum tilt Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Freestanding: 20 feet when oriented at maximum tilt Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Freestanding: 20 feet when oriented at maximum tilt Building mounted: Shall not exceed the maximum allowed building height Freestanding: 20 feet when oriented at maximum tilt Building mount- ed: Shall not exceed the maxi- mum allowed building height Free- standing: 20 feet when oriented at maxi-mum tilt Television and Radio Antennae Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof Not to exceed 12 feet above the roof 129 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table 8: Zoning District Site Development Standards for Accessory Structures Accessory Structure Type R1 R2 R3 NC Commercial TC Industrial AP NOTES: [1] The tower shall be located only in the rear yard, and set back at least 15 feet from any property line. However, necessary guy wires, anchors, and wires of less than 1/4 inch may be set back at least 3 feet from any rear or interior side property line. [2] On interior lots abutting directly on Twin Lake, a detached accessory garage, carport, shed, accessory dwelling unit, or workshop may be erected within the front setback area provided it does not encroach into the required front, side or corner side setback. [3] Garages, carports, accessory dwelling units, or workshops in the side or rear yard may be located as close as 3 feet to the property line provided that no part of the building, including eaves and foundation, is within the 3 foot area and does not encroach into a platted or dedicated easement. [4] If the vehicle entrance for a detached garage or carport faces a street or alley, the garage or carport shall be at least 20 feet from the corner side or rear property line. [5] For building-mounted solar energy systems, the collector surface and mounting devices shall not extend beyond the required setbacks on which the building is mounted. For freestanding solar energy systems, the system may not extend into the following setbacks when oriented at minimum design tilt: Front: 30 feet, but cannot be located closer to the street than the principal building; Side: 5 feet; Rear: 5 feet; Corner side: 10 feet. [6] For the purposes of this maximum height requirement, detached accessory buildings are defined as carports, detached garages, gazebos, noncommercial greenhouses, sheds and workshops. Some of these structures may not be allowed in every zoning district. 520.05 Architectural design standards for principal buildings. Subd. 1. Intent. It is not the intent of the city to unduly restrict design freedom when reviewing project architecture in connection with a site plan for a principal building. However, it is in the best interest of the city to promote high standards of architectural design and compatibility with surrounding structures and neighborhoods. Subd. 2. Exterior design and materials. Except for warehouse and industrial buildings that are adequately screened from view, the following are not allowed for building exteriors: (a) Except for airplane hangars and data centers in the AP district, Blank blank walls; (b) Unadorned prestressed concrete panels; (c) Concrete block; and (d) Unfinished metal and corrugated metal, except for airplane hangars at the Crystal Airport which may have a corrugated metal exterior. 520.07. Exterior lighting. Subd. 1. Standards. Exterior lighting is subject to the following standards: (a) Any exterior lighting that is used to illuminate an off-street parking area, sign or other structure shall be hooded or controlled in some manner so as to deflect light away from any adjoining residential property or from public streets; 130 CR225-464-620540.v15 (b) Exterior lighting which casts light on a public street shall not exceed one foot candle at the property line abutting the street and lighting which casts light on residential property shall not exceed 0.4 foot candle at the property line abutting that residential property; and (c) Bare light bulbs shall not be permitted if they can be viewed from adjacent property or the public right-of-way. 520.09. Fences and retaining walls. Subd. 1. Fence requirements. (a) Height requirements. (1) Measurement of fence height. The height of a fence shall be measured as follows: (i) Fence height is measured from the average grade to the tallest part of the fence, including posts; (ii) In cases where the fence is located on sloped grade, the fence height shall be measured separately for each segment between posts; and (iii) In the case of grade being changed where the fence is to be located, such as when fill is added or berm is created, the maximum fence height shall be measured from the grade at the principal structure or the property line, whichever is closer to the proposed fence. (2) Fences in residential districts. Fences in residential districts shall comply with the following: (i) For interior lots, fences shall not be taller than 4.5 feet in the front yard and 6.5 feet in the side or rear yard (see Figure 16); and Figure 16: Fence height on interior residential lot (ii) For fences on corner lots, a the fence height in the front and corner side yards is determined by which side the principal building faces (see Figures 17 and 18) property owner may choose which yard will have a 6.5 foot tall fence provided that no fence 131 CR225-464-620540.v15 will exceed 4.5 feet in height in any yard between the front entry of the principal building and any public street (see Figures 17 and 18). Figure 17: Fence location on corner residential lot (principal building facing shorter side) Figure 18: Fence location on corner residential lot (principal building facing longer side) (3) Fences in non-residential districts. Fences in non-residential districts, including the TC- PD district, shall comply with the following: (i) For interior lots, fences shall not be taller than 4.5 feet in the front yard and 8.5 feet in the side or rear yard; and (ii) For corner lots, fence height is determined in the same manner as for corner residential lots (see Figures 17 and 18), except that the maximum height shall be 8.5 feet where a 6.5 feet fence is allowed. 145 CR225-464-620540.v15 Traffic into and out of business areas shall to the maximum extent possible, be forward moving with no backing into streets. (f)Off-street parking of motor vehicles and recreational vehicles and equipment. Motor vehicles and recreational vehicles and equipment may be parked or stored outside as provided in the Crystal City Code, chapter 13. If parked or stored outside, motor vehicles and recreational vehicles and equipment shall have current valid registration including clearly visible license plate tabs. One-and-two family dwellings and lawful Lawful vehicle sales businesses in commercial or industrial districts are exempt from this requirement. Subd. 4. Rules for computation. (a)Calculation. The following rules shall apply when computing parking spaces: (1)Driveway space meeting parking requirements. Entrances, exits, or driveways shall not be computed as any part of a required parking lot or area, except in the case of one or two family dwellings where driveways may be used in calculating the amount of off-street parking; (2)Multiple uses. Unless otherwise noted or approved, off-street parking areas serving more than one use shall provide parking in an amount equal to the combined total of the requirements for each use. The required base number of parking spaces shall be counted only once for multiple use buildings; (3)Area measurements. All square-footage-based parking standards shall be computed on the basis of gross floor area of all floors in a nonresidential building. Up to 15 percent of the gross floor area may be excluded from the above calculation if the area is used for storage, loading, unloading, or for mechanical equipment; and (4)Vehicle fuel stations. Spaces at the pump at a vehicle fuel station may count toward the minimum parking space requirements. (b)Occupancy-or capacity-based standards. (1)For the purpose of computing parking requirements based on employees, students, residents, or occupants, calculations shall be based on the typical, or average, number of persons working on a single shift or the typical enrollment, whichever is applicable. (2)In hospitals, bassinets shall not be counted as beds. (3)In the case of benches, pews, and similar seating accommodations, each 24 inches thereof shall be counted as one seat for the purpose of determining the parking requirements. If fixed seating is not provided, then each seven square feet of floor area shall be counted as one seat. (c)Unlisted uses. (1)Upon receiving an application for a use not specifically listed in the parking schedule below, the zoning administrator shall apply the parking standard specified for the listed use that is deemed most similar to the proposed use in regards to use, size, and intensity of use. (2)If the zoning administrator determines that there is no listed use similar to the proposed use, intensity, or size, they may refer to the estimates of parking demand based on 153 CR225-464-620540.v15 Revised Figure 27: (2) An auxiliary space cannot exceed 12 feet in width and 24 feet in length, and must be at least ten feet from the habitable portion of a residential structure on an adjacent property; and (3) For access to the auxiliary space, a hard surfaced taper also is permitted, provided it does not extend into in the boulevard provided that the taper is at least three feet back from the curb so that the driveway approach does not exceed the curb cut width at that point (see Option #1 of Figure 27). and has an angle of at least 22-1/2 degrees and no more than 45 degrees. If the property has setback or topographic constraints that prevent reasonable access to a lawful auxiliary space, then the city engineer may allow the taper to extend into the boulevard but only to the minimum extent necessary to provide reasonable access. Subd. 10. Setbacks. Except for off-street parking lots within the TC and TC-PD districts, which have separate requirements in paragraph (d) of this subdivision, all parking lots are subject to the setback requirements in paragraphs (a) through (c) of this subdivision. (a) The face of the curb shall not be within five feet of any property line and the back of the curb shall not be within four feet of any property line. (b) If a parking lot for a commercial, institutional, or multiple family dwelling use is adjacent to a property used for one or two-family residential dwellings, the face of the curb for the parking lot shall not be within ten feet of the shared property line and the back of the curb shall not be within nine feet of the shared property line. This setback may be reduced to five feet to the property line and four feet to the back of the curb if a permanent opaque screen fence or wall of at least 6.5 feet in height is installed to screen the parking lot from the residential dwellings. The screen fence may exceed typical height limitations as allowed in the Crystal city code, subsection 520.09, subd. 1 (a) (3) (iii). (c) All setbacks near intersections of public streets shall be determined by the city engineer. (d) Within the TC and TC-PD districts, if a parking lot is constructed it shall be subject to the following setback and locational requirements: (1) Location. Off-street parking lots are prohibited in front of the building, but may be located to the rear or side of buildings (see Figure 28); 155 CR225-464-620540.v15 Figure 29: Non-impeded access driveway. (iv)A minimum unobstructed clearance height of 14 feet shall be maintained above areas accessible to vehicles within nonresidential developments. (3)To ensure proper location and configuration, a permit is required from the city manager or designee for work on driveways. For driveway plans that involve changes to an existing curb cut or construction of a new curb cut within the public right-of-way, a right of way permit application shall be approved in accordance with the Crystal city code, chapter VIII. (4)If a driveway or driveway taper extends over or otherwise covers a water curb stop, a traffic-rated access cover or access cover approved by the city shall be installed over the curb stop. The access cover is subject to the following standards: i.Be of sufficient strength and construction to withstand anticipated vehicle loads; and ii.Provide continual access to the water curb stop without requiring removal or demolition of the driveway or taper; and iii. Be located and constructed in accordance to the city’s water utility standards; and iv.The city may require the property owner to replace, repair, or modify the access cover if it becomes damaged, inaccessible, unsafe, or otherwise unsuitable for continual use. (b)Parking space dimensions. (1)Required dimensions. Each parking space and aisle shall comply with the minimum dimensions in Table 12 as illustrated in Figure 30. Table 12: Parking Space and Aisle Dimensions Angle of Parking (degrees) One-Way Maneuvering Aisle Width (Feet) “A” Two-Way Maneuvering Aisle Width (Feet) “A” Parking Stall Width (Feet) “B” Parking Stall Length (Feet) “C” Compact Size Low Turnover Full Size Compact Size Low Turnover Full Size 0 o – Parallel 12 20 8 8.5 9 18 22 22 30 o – 53o 14 20 8 8.5 9 16 20 20 182 CR225-464-620540.v15 Subd. 3. Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited: (a) Any sign, signal, marking or device which purports to be or is an imitation of or resembles any official traffic control device or railroad sign or signal, or emergency vehicle signal, or which attempts to direct the movement of traffic or which hides from view or interferes with the effectiveness of any official traffic-control device or any railroad sign or signal; (b) All off-premise signs; (c) Signs painted, attached or in any other manner affixed to trees, rocks, or similar natural surfaces, or attached to public utility poles, bridges, towers, or similar public structures; (d) Signs placed in the public right-of-way, other than the following: (i) Governmental signs; (ii) Courtesy bench signs allowed with an obstruction permit as regulated by the Crystal city code, chapter VIII; (iii) Except for home businesses and garage and yard sales, which have separate sign requirements in the Crystal city code sections 515.23 and 515.27, respectively, Signs signs placed in public right-of-way that are maintained by the owner or occupant of residential property abutting said right-of-way. Each sign is limited to 30 inches in height and six square feet in area, and the cumulative area of all signs is limited to 0.5 square feet of sign area per lineal foot of frontage on the right-of-way; and (iv) Sandwich board signs are permitted in the public right-of-way but shall not interfere with public use of the sidewalk or right-of-way. The city’s public works director has authority to determine if a sign is interfering. (e) A sign, including unshielded display lighting, that obstructs or distracts the vision of drivers or pedestrians, or detracts from the visibility of any official traffic control device; (f) A sign that contains, imitates, interferes with, obscures or causes confusion with an official traffic sign or signal, except for private, on premise directional signs; (g) Abandoned signs; (h) Roof signs; and (i) Vehicle signs. 530.05. Sign design standards. Subd. 1. Computations. The following principles shall control the computation of sign area and sign height: (a) The area of a sign face, which is also the sign area of a wall sign or other sign with only one face, shall be computed by means of the smallest square, circle, rectangle, triangle, or combination thereof that shall encompass the extreme limits of the writing, representation, emblem, or other display. This does not include any supporting framework, bracing, or 184 CR225-464-620540.v15 height for a specific sign type from ground level and shall be located on land in an area which is landscaped or if such land is part of an approved parking area, it shall be surfaced or paved as required in this UDC. Subd. 4. Illumination. External illumination for signs shall be so constructed and maintained that the source of light meets the requirements of the Crystal city code, subsection 520.07. In addition, illuminated signs, including electronically or electrically controlled readerboards, within 500 feet of a one family attached or detached dwelling or a two-family dwelling shall not be illuminated between the hours of 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. Subd. 5. Intersections. A sign or sign structure shall comply with the visibility requirements in the Crystal city code, chapter VIII. 530.07. Maintenance and repair. Subd. 1. Maintenance. Every sign shall be maintained in a safe, presentable and good structural condition at all times, including the replacement of defective parts, painting, repainting, cleaning and other acts required for the maintenance of the sign. Subd. 2. Repairs. (a) Any sign located in the city which may now be or hereafter become out of order, rotten or unsafe, and every sign which shall hereafter be erected, altered, resurfaced, reconstructed or moved contrary to the provisions of this subsection, shall be removed or otherwise properly secured in accordance with the terms of this subsection by the owners thereof or by the owners of the grounds on which said sign shall stand, upon written notice by the city. No rotten or other unsafe sign shall be repaired or rebuilt except in accordance with the provisions of this subsection and upon a permit issued by the city. (b) In the event of the failure of the owner or person, company or corporation having control of any sign, or the owner of the ground on which the sign is located, to remove or repair said sign within 60 days after the use is terminated, a written notice shall be given and the sign may be removed by the city at the expense of the owner or manager of the sign, or the owner of the ground upon which the sign stands. 530.09. Allowed sign types. (a) Table 14 lists the sign types allowed within each zoning district. The symbols and headings used in the table are defined as follows: (1) A “P” in a cell indicates a sign type that is allowed in the zoning district with an approved sign permit application; (2) An “A” in a cell indicates a sign type that is allowed in the zoning district, but is exempt from obtaining a sign permit; (3) A cell with a “-“ indicates a sign type that is not allowed in the zoning district; and (4) The “sign specific standards” column cross-references standards that are specific to an individual sign type and are applicable to that sign in all districts unless otherwise stated in the sign specific standards. 185 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table: 14: Signs allowed by zoning district Sign Type Zoning District Sign Specific Standards R-1 R-2 R-3 NC C TC I AP Canopy, Marquee, and Fixed Awnings P P P P P P P P 530.11, subdivision 1 Electronically or electrically controlled readerboard P P P P P - P P 530.11, subdivision 2 Electric P P P P P P P P Freestanding - - - - P - P P 530.11, subdivision 3 Governmental A A A A A A A A Monument P P P P P P P P 530.11, subdivision 4 Multiple Tenant - - - P P P P - 530.11, subdivision 6 Off-Premise - - - - - - - - Projecting - - - P P P P P 530.11, subdivision 5 Roof - - - - - - - - Rotating - - - - - - - - Sandwich board - - - P P P - - 530.11, subdivision 7 Shimmering - - - - P - P P Temporary P P P P P P P P 530.11, subdivision 8 Small A A A P A A A A Wall P P P P P P P P 530.11, subdivision 9 530.11. Sign specific standards. The following requirements for specific sign types apply in addition to those requirements found in Table 14. Subd. 1. Canopies, marquees and fixed awnings. Signs are allowed on canopies, marquees and fixed awnings, which are an integral part of the structure to which they are attached. Within the residential districts, these signs are only allowed for multiple family dwellings, or institutional or commercial uses, 186 CR225-464-620540.v15 but are allowed for all building types in the commercial and industrial districts. Canopy, marquee, and fixed awning signs are subject to the following standards: (a) An awning, canopy or marquee may not project into the public right-of-way nearer than 30 inches to the street curb or curb line; (b) The bottom of awning signs shall be no less than eight feet above the sidewalk or grade at any point; (c) Awnings, canopy or marquees projecting into the required yards may not be enclosed except with a transparent material permitting through vision; (d) Awnings, canopies or marquees built over the public right-of-way must be included in a liability insurance policy holding the city free of all responsibility; and (e) Canopies and marquees are a part of the building structure but the area of canopies and marquees may not be used in the computation of total wall area. Subd. 2. Electronically or electrically controlled readerboards. Electronically or electrically controlled readerboards are permitted provided that the sign: (a) Displays a given copy or graphic image for a minimum of three seconds within the readerboard frame if having lamps of a single color, or for a minimum of sixty seconds if having lamps of more than one color; (b) Is included in an otherwise permitted and conforming wall, free-standing or monument sign, and the area of the readerboard may not exceed 50% of the sign face in which it is integrated, or 50 square feet, whichever is less, and only one readerboard per premise is allowed; (c) Displays a static message with no fade, dissolve, scrolling, blinking, flashing, spinning or zooming action; and (d) Does not cast light on any public street in excess of one foot candle at the lot line along said street, or in excess of 0.4 foot candle at the lot line of any residential property. (e) In the NC district, copy or graphic images for an electronic readerboard shall not be displayed between the hours of 9:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. Subd. 3. Freestanding or pylon signs. Freestanding or pylon signs are subject to the following standards: (a) Freestanding or pylon signs shall meet the requirements in Table 15; and (b) An electronically or electrically controlled reader board is allowed as part of a freestanding or pylon sign. 187 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table: 15: Freestanding or Pylon Signs Sign Type Number Allowed Maximum Height Area Minimum Street Frontage Setback From Lot Line Setback From Right-of- Way Freestanding or pylon sign 1 [1] 25 feet 1 square foot of sign per linear foot of frontage [2] 50 feet 10 feet, and 50 feet from residential use, park, school, library, church or similar land use [3] 10 feet Notes: 1. A property abutting more than one street may have one additional freestanding sign on one of the additional street rights-of-way provided that such right-of-way is on an arterial or collector street and such sign is more than 50 feet distant from any other freestanding sign on the property. 2. The area of a sign may not exceed the following square footages based on the street the sign abuts: 1. Principal arterial - 200 square feet 2. Minor arterial or major collector – 150 square feet 3. Minor collector – 100 square feet. For the purposes of this UDC, frontage roads are defined as minor collector streets. 4. Local – 50 square feet 3. All parts of a freestanding sign (supports, structure, display, or trim) shall meet this setback requirement. Subd. 4. Monument signs. Monument signs are subject to the following standards: (b) In the residential districts, monuments signs are only allowed for multiple family dwellings or institutional or commercial uses; (c) Monument signs shall meet the requirements in Table 16; and (d) Except in the TC district, an electronically or electrically controlled reader board is allowed as part of a monument sign. Table: 16: Monument Signs Sign Type Number Allowed Maximum Height Area Setback From Any Property Line Setback From Right-of- Way Monument 1 [1] 6 feet in R-1, R-2, R-3, NC and TC; 25 feet in C, I and AP Maximum 75 square feet in R-1, R-2, R-3 and TC; same area requirements as 10 feet 10 feet 189 CR225-464-620540.v15 (b) Freestanding signs. Where allowed, one freestanding sign shall be permitted for each multiple- tenant building. (c) Canopies and awnings. The design of canopies shall be in keeping with the overall building design in terms of location, size, and color. No canopies with visible wall hangers shall be permitted. Signage on canopies may be substituted for allowed building signage and shall be limited to 25% of the canopy area. Subd. 7. Sandwich board signs. Sandwich board signs are subject to the following standards: (a) Signs shall not exceed six square feet in size; (b) One sign is allowed per property. Within the TC district, and for multiple tenant commercial buildings on one property, one sign is allowed per business; and (c) Signs shall only be displayed during business operating hours. Subd. 8. Temporary signs. Except for those signs specifically exempt in the Crystal city code subsection 530.03, subdivision 2, the temporary use of banners, pennants, balloon signs, portable signs and similar devices requires a permit. The permit is valid for seven consecutive days. Not more than six permits for each property, or if applicable each tenant in a multiple tenant building, may be granted in a 12-month period. The permit must be prominently displayed at the principal use in the same manner required for building permits. Temporary signs shall not exceed 50 square feet in area and eight feet in height and shall conform to the relevant location requirements in the Crystal city code section 530.03, subdivision 3. Subd. 9. Wall signs. (a) Wall signs in residential districts. In the residential districts, wall signs are allowed for multiple family dwellings, or institutional or commercial uses, subject to the following standards: (1) Wall signs are only permitted on walls fronting on a public street or facing other property used for institutional, commercial or industrial purposes. (2) No more than one sign is permitted on each wall. (3) No wall sign shall exceed 10% of the wall area or 75 square feet in area, whichever is less. (4) Wall signs for home business are allowed according to the requirements in the Crystal city code, subsection 515.23. (b) Wall signs in commercial and industrial districts. In the TC, NC, C, and I commercial and industrial districts, wall signs are subject to the following standards: (1) Wall signs shall meet the requirements in Table 18; 190 CR225-464-620540.v15 Table: 18: Wall Signs Sign Type Number Allowed Area Wall Maximum of 2 wall or projecting signs per wall Up to 10% of the wall area to which it is affixed when combined with projecting signs (2) Buildings exceeding 80,000 square feet in size on lots of over 20,000 square feet are permitted to have wall/projecting signage of up to 250 square feet; and (3) A wall sign may be displayed on the side or rear of a building facing a yard not abutting on a street under the following conditions: (i) The sign is visible from a public roadway on which the building abuts; (ii) The side or rear yard on the side of the building to be signed must meet district setback requirements; (iii) The sign(s) may not be larger in area than the largest sign permitted elsewhere on the building; and (iv) If the side or rear yard on the side of the building to be signed abuts a park property or a residential use, any lighting of sign must be shielded in accordance with the Crystal city code, subsection 520.07. Subd. 10. Signs containing non-commercial speech. (a) Substitution clause. The owner of any sign which is otherwise allowed by these sign regulations may substitute non-commercial copy in lieu of any commercial or non-commercial copy. This substitution of copy may be made without any additional approval or permitting. The purpose of this provision is to prevent any inadvertent favoring of commercial speech over non-commercial speech, or favoring of any particular non-commercial message over any other non-commercial message. This provision prevails over any more specific provision to the contrary. (b) Notwithstanding any other provisions of these sign requirements, all signs of any size containing non-commercial speech may be posted from August 1 as allowed by Minnesota Statute section 211B.045 in for any general or special election year until ten days following the general election and 13 weeks prior to any special election until ten days following the special election. (c) Signs containing non-commercial speech that are posted outside the time limits in subdivision 10(b) of this subsection shall not exceed 50 square feet in area and eight feet in height and shall conform to the relevant locational requirements in the Crystal city code subsection 530.03, subdivision 3. Included four R-1 properties in UO-PD 4222 Brunswick Ave. N. is included in UO-PD 4171 Adair Ave. N. is included in UO-PD Single-family homes on Edgewood Ave. N. are not included in UO-PD district Attachment B Attachment C (G)Construction design requirements. (1)Exterior building materials. Exterior building materials are classified as primary or secondary. Primary materials must comprise at least 60% of the building facade. Secondary materials must comprise no more than 40% of the building facade. (a)Primary materials in the B-1, B-2, B-3, B-5 and B-6 Zoning Districts. Primary exterior building materials in the B-1, B-2, B-3, B- 5 and B-6 Districts include brick, stone, stucco, glass, or other similar maintenance-free materials that are designed for durability as proven through industry standards and approved through the site plan review process. Materials must be colored only by means of a pigment integral to the material, not applied to the surface. (b)Primary materials in the B-4, I-1 and I-2 Zoning Districts. Primary exterior building materials in the B-4, I-1 and I-2 Districts include brick, stone, stucco, glass, concrete masonry units (CMU) which are textured, burnished or decorative, or other similar maintenance-free materials designed for durability as proven through industry standards and approved through the site plan review process. Materials must be colored only by means of a pigment integral to the material, not applied to the surface. (c)Secondary materials in the B-1, B-2, B-3, B-5 and B-6 Zoning Districts. Secondary exterior building materials in the B-1, B-2, B-3, B-5 and B-6 Districts include, textured, burnished or decorative integrally colored block, or synthetic stucco above eight feet. Materials must be colored only by means of a pigment integral to the material, not applied to the surface. Other secondary exterior building materials include wood or metal. Any metal surface must be coated or anodized with a non-reflective glare-free finish. (d)Secondary materials in the B-4, I-1 and I-2 Zoning Districts. Secondary exterior building materials in the B-4, I-1 and I-2 Districts include synthetic stucco above eight feet, wood or metal. Any metal surface must be coated or anodized with a non-reflective glare-free finish. (2)In the B-1, B-2, B-3, B-4, B-5 and B-6 Districts, all exterior vertical surfaces must be treated as a front and be equally attractive on all sides of the structure. (3)Window coverage in B-1, B-2, B-3, B-5 and B-6 Zoning Districts, buildings containing office and retail uses must maintain at least 40% window coverage on each first floor front that faces a street, parking lot or open space. (4)Building facades in B-1, B-2, B-3, B-4, B-5 and B-6 Zoning Districts, all exterior building walls adjacent to a street, parking lot or open space must not exceed 60 feet in length without visual relief of two or more of the following: (a)The facade is divided architecturally with different materials or textures; (b)There are horizontal offsets of at least two feet in depth; (c)There are vertical offsets in the roof line of at least two feet; and (d)The windows on the first floor are recessed horizontally at least one foot. 8/24/26, 8:53 AM § 153.031 SITE PLAN APPROVAL PROCEDURE AND DESIGN REQUIREMENTS IN RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS. https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/weststpaul/latest/weststpaul_mn/0-0-0-5247#JD_153.031 1/1 West St. PaulAttachment D a) b) c) d) e) f) g) a) b) 544.07. - Architectural standards. Subdivision 1.[Generally.] Architectural plans shall be prepared by an architect or other qualified person and shall show the following: Elevations of all sides of the building; Type and color of exterior building materials; Typical floor plans; Dimensions of all structures; The location of trash containers and of exterior electrical, heating, ventilation, and air conditioning equipment; Utility plans including water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer; and Additional plans deemed necessary by the Director. Subd. 2.Building orientation. Buildings shall be oriented so that at least one (1) principal entrance faces the public street. On corner lots where the intersecting streets have different classifications, the principal entrance shall face the street with the higher classification. Building entrances shall: Be architecturally emphasized and highly visible from the street; and Utilize design features that protect pedestrians from the rain and sun, such as awnings, canopies, or porticos; See also Section 509.07, Subd. 5 (Amended Bill No. 2025-12) Subd. 3.Exterior Materials. The exterior wall surfaces of all non-residential structures shall be constructed of wood, brick, stone, cementitious planks (e.g., Hardiplank®), glass, architectural concrete textured surfaces or other materials of high quality as approved by the Director. The exterior wall surface for all residential structures shall be constructed of wood, brick, stone, cementitious planks (e.g., Hardiplank®), glass or other materials of high quality as approved by the Director. Finished metals shall be used only above the ground floor and shall not exceed 40 percent of any exterior wall surface and may not have a metallic finish. For both residential and non-residential structures, unadorned pre-stressed concrete panels, standard concrete block and unfinished metal, except naturally weathering metals such as copper, shall not be permitted as exterior materials for buildings. This restriction shall apply to all principal structures and to all accessory buildings, including parking ramps, except those accessory buildings not visible from any exterior lot line. (Amended Bill No. 2025-12) Subd. 4.Architectural Design/Compatibility. The exterior architectural appearance of the proposed structure shall not be so at variance with the exterior architectural appearance of existing structures within the immediate area, or with the intended character of the applicable zoning districts, taking into 8/21/26, 1:51 PM Richfield, MN Code of Ordinances about:blank 1/3 Richfield a) b) i. ii. iii. consideration building materials, size, shape and heights, so as to cause an adverse impact upon property values in the immediate area, or the City as a whole, or adversely affect the public health, safety and general welfare of the portion of the City in which the property is located, or the City as a whole. Subd. 5.Window Treatment. For both residential and non-residential structures, windows or false windows shall, at a minimum, be used on the ground level of any wall parallel to or nearly parallel to a street. The use of bars, chains or similar security devices that are visible from a public street or sidewalk shall be prohibited. (Amended Bill No. 2025-12) Window requirements for residential structures shall include: Each building wall that faces a public street, public sidewalk or public pathway, must be comprised of no less than 30 percent windows on the first floor and no less than 20 percent windows on each floor above the first floor. Each building wall that faces any other direction must be comprised of no less than 15 percent windows on each floor. False windows are prohibited. Residential window requirements are not intended to require custom window sizes or to increase building setbacks to comply with building code. They are intended to apply in cases when the first floor is used for interior parking. (Amended Bill No. 2025-12) Subd. 6.Equal Façade Treatment. All buildings shall be constructed so that each exterior wall and roof surface is finished with materials of consistent quality as those of the front wall and front roof. This requirement, however, shall not be applicable to walls or roof surfaces which are completely screened from view by other buildings. Subd. 7.Façade Treatment of Accessory Structures. All structures, including parking ramps shall be designed to be architecturally integrated into the overall site and be made of comparable materials and decorative elements. Subd. 8.Façade Maintenance. All façade treatments shall be maintained so as to not be unsightly in appearance or in a state of disrepair, nor shall harmful health or safety conditions be present for the life of the project. Subd. 9.Color. No residential structure may display more than ten (10) percent of any elevation surface in bright, high intensity or pure tone primary or secondary colors. No fluorescent or neon colors shall be used on any exterior elevation surface. City-approved murals are exempt from this limitation. (Added Bill No. 2025-12) 8/21/26, 1:51 PM Richfield, MN Code of Ordinances about:blank 2/3 Subd. 10.Blank Walls. Residential building elevations shall consistently incorporate elements that relate to the human scale. No wall shall be uninterrupted for more than 25 feet in length as calculated per floor. Interruptions may include doors and windows, projections, recessions, awnings and canopies, decorative ornamentation or other architectural elements. This requirement may also be addressed through art installation or living walls, subject to approval by the Director. (Added Bill No. 2025-12) Subd. 11.Building Mass. No residential building wall shall exceed 200 feet in length. Every residential building wall length that exceeds the height of the building shall incorporate full height offsets spaced at intervals equal to or less than the building height. The offset shall be a minimum of one (1) foot in depth and width per story of building height. An offset can be a projection or recess. Building walls under 36 feet in length are exempt from this standard. (Added Bill No. 2025-12) 8/21/26, 1:51 PM Richfield, MN Code of Ordinances about:blank 3/3 f.The city acknowledges a degree of flexibility may be necessary to adjust to unique situations. Alternatives that provide an increase in pedestrian vibrancy and street safety including but not limited to public art and pedestrian scale amenities may be considered and may be approved by the Zoning Administrator, unless the development application requires approval by city council, in which case the city council shall approve the alternate transparency plan. (Ord. No. 2595-20, 10-19-20; Ord. No. 2602-21, 1-4-21) (c)Building Materials. Exterior surface materials of buildings shall be installed and maintained in accordance with the adopted building code and the manufacturer’s specifications and shall be subject to the regulations listed below. Products listed as “integral colored” shall continue its surface color consistently through the depth of the product as opposed to being colored, painted, or stained on the surface only. (1)Classes of materials. Materials shall be divided into class I, class II and class III categories as follows: a.Class I. The following materials are considered class 1 materials as specified: 1.Brick 2.Marble, granite, or other natural stone 3.Integral colored cast stone (the stone is colored consistently through) 4.Textured cement stucco 5.Architectural wall cladding (Nichiha, Equitone and similar brands) Material must be through colored and at least 5/8 inches thick. 6.Copper 7.Porcelain 8.Glass 9.Wall mounted solar energy system 10.Residential buildings containing four or fewer dwelling units may utilize the following additional materials: i.Wood ii.Vinyl siding iii.Fiber-reinforced cement board iv.Prefinished metal 11.Residential buildings containing five or more dwelling units may utilize the following additional materials: i.Up to 10% of the required class 1 materials may be finished with clapboard and/or shake-style fiber-reinforced cement board with a minimum thickness of ¼ inch. 12.Park buildings under 3,000 square feet may utilize the following additional materials: i.Wood. b.Class II. The following materials are considered class II materials as specified: 1.Exposed aggregate concrete panels 2.Burnished concrete block 3.Integral colored split face (rock face) and exposed aggregate concrete block 4.Cast-in-place concrete 5.Insulated exterior wall panels (E.I.F.S., Drivit and similar brands) § 36-366 Architectural Design Supp. No. 43 (01-23) 36:V:52 St. Louis Park Zoning Code St. Louis Park 6.Fiber-reinforced cement board siding with a minimum thickness of ¼ inch 7.Prefinished metal. 8.Integral colored concrete panels other than smooth finished. c.Class III. The following materials are considered class III materials as specified: 1.Unpainted or surface painted concrete block (scored or unscored) 2.Unpainted or surface painted plain or ribbed concrete panels 3.Unfinished or surface painted metal 4.Smooth finished concrete panels 5.Brick, stone, or integral colored material which has been painted (2)New construction minimum class I materials. At least 60 percent of each building face visible from off the site must be of class I materials except as permitted by subsection (d)(4)c. of this section. Not more than 10 percent of each building face visible from off the site may be of class III materials. Portions of buildings not visible from off the site may be constructed of greater percentages of class II or class III materials if the structure otherwise conforms to all city ordinances. The mixture of building materials must be compatible and integrated. (3)New construction buildings in I-G and I-P districts. a.Not on major streets and not near residential. For buildings in the I-G and I-P districts which are not located on a principal arterial, minor arterial, major collector, or adjacent to or across from any neighborhood zoned property, class I materials may be reduced to a minimum of 25 percent provided that the remaining materials are functionally and durably equal to a class I material as certified by the architect or manufacturer. b.On major streets or near residential. For building walls in the I-G and I-P districts facing on a principal arterial, minor arterial or major collector, or adjacent to or across from any neighborhood zoned property, class I materials may be reduced to a minimum of 25 percent provided that the remaining materials are functionally and durably equal to a class I material as certified by the architect or manufacturer and that the architectural design and site plan are superior quality as determined by the zoning administrator. The architecture and site plan shall meet the following minimum criteria to be considered superior quality: 1.The exposed height of the building wall shall not exceed 15 feet. 2.The number of required plant units shall be increased by 20 percent or the size of 20 percent of the overstory trees installed shall be increased to 3 1/2 caliper inches. 3.A minimum of ten percent of the building facade must be windows or glass spandrels. (4)Existing buildings. Existing buildings may paint or stain their exterior utilizing product specifically formulated for its intended use. All painted or stained surfaces shall be maintained so it is free of chipping and peeling. (5)Temporary materials. On non-residential properties, covered patios with a permanent solid roof may enclose the wall openings with transparent non-glass materials for up to six months per calendar year provided the permanent exterior wall materials are not covered. (Ord. No. 2640-22, 1-18-22; Ord. No. 2662-23, 3-20-23; Ord. No. 2690-25, 3-3-25) Architectural Design § 36-366 Supp. No. 46 (03-25) 36:V:53 St. Louis Park Zoning Code 102-710 Generally ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 7-2 102-720 Roof Types �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7-2 102-730 Entrance Types ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 7-6 102-740 Facade Materials ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7-8 102-750 Facade Elements ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7-14 102-760 Utility Equipment ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7-20 Article 7 BUilDiNG DeSiGN 7-1CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Hopkins 102-710 Generally 102-710 (a) APPLICABILITY The regulations of this article apply to all buildings in all zones, unless otherwise stated. 102-710 (b) INTENT The regulations of this Article 7, along with the building type regulations in Article 3, are intended to improve the physical quality of buildings, improve the long-term value and durability of buildings, enhance the pedestrian experience, and protect the historic form and scale of the City. (1)Durable, High Quality. Ensure the use of well-tested, high quality, durable, weather-resistant, exterior grade materials on the majority of finished building surfaces, while permitting a wider range of materials for details. High quality materials can improve how well buildings weather, reduce material failure rate, require lower maintenance, have a longer life cycle and sense of permanence, and maintain longer term value. (2)Human-Scaled Facades. Promote clearly articulated, well-organized facades that are easy to understand, have a clear hierarchy, and yield building proportions and details comfortable to and in line with the scale of people. 102-710 (c) FRANCHISE ARCHITECTURE Franchise architecture is building design that is trademarked or identified with a particular franchise, chain or corporation, used in multiple locations without being specific to the context, and is generic or standard in nature. (1)Not Allowed. To maintain the unique character of the downtown, franchise architectural design is not allowed in any zone with the -D suffix. (2)Unique Design. Franchises or national chains must follow the building type regulations and design standards of this article to create a unique building compatible with the downtown. 102-720 Roof Types 102-720 (a) GENERAL REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO ALL ROOF TYPES (1)Roof types apply to all mixed-use zones in Article 3. (2)The major components of any roof must meet all the requirements of one of the roof types allowed per the building type regulations in Article 3. (3)Roofs for bay or bow windows and dormers are not required to meet a roof type. (4)Terraces, green roofs, rooftop gardens, and other outdoor facilities are allowed on any roof and are not considered a roof type. However, any permanently covered area is considered a story and must meet the following: a.Where a cover is visible from any public way or open space, the cover must comply with a roof type. b.Any fully enclosed structure on a roof must meet the tower regulations. 102-720 (b) OTHER ROOF TYPES Other cap designs not defined in this section may be approved by the zoning administrator with the following requirements: (1)Special Building. The building or portion of building receiving the roof type must warrant a separate status from the majority of buildings in the zone, with a correspondence between the form of the roof and the building use, such as a dome for a planetarium, a dome for a place of worship, or a unique, iconic roof for a more distinctive performing arts venue. (2)Occupied Building Space. The roof type must not create additional occupiable floor space beyond that permitted by the building type. (3)Other Design. The shape of the roof must be different from those defined in this section, 102-720, such as a dome, spire, or vault and not a gabled roof, hipped roof, parapet roof, or flat roof. 102-720 (c) PARAPET ROOF TYPE A parapet is a low wall projecting above a building’s roof along the perimeter of the building on all street facades and other front facades. See Figure 7-A Example of a Parapet Roof. (1)Parapet Height. Height is measured from the top of the upper story to the top of the parapet. a.Minimum height is 1.5 feet with a maximum height of 6 feet. Up to 2 additional feet of height may be approved for screening of mechanical equipment. 7-2 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-710 Generally b.A shadow line must be located within 2 feet of the top of the uppermost story. See 102-16210 for definition of shadow line. c.A shadow line must be located at the top of the parapet. See 102-16210 for definition of shadow line. (2)Occupied Building Space. Occupied building space must not be incorporated behind this roof type. See 102- 16170 for definition of occupied building space. (3)Rooftop Appurtenances. With the exception of solar panels and small wind, any rooftop appurtenances must be located towards the rear or interior of the parapet roof. Rooftop appurtenances should be located such that the parapet blocks their view from the sidewalk across the street or may be located within a tower per 102-720 (f). See 102-760 for additional regulations of mechanical and utility equipment. Figure 7-A. Example of a Parapet Roof type Roof Roof HeightHeight Shadow Shadow lineslines upper floorupper floor 102-720 (d) FLAT ROOF TYPE This roof type is a visibly flat roof with overhanging eaves. See Figure 7-B Example of a Tower. (1)Maximum Slope. The maximum slope is 2:12; however, the roof must not appear to be visibly sloped from the street or other front frontages. (2)Eaves. Eaves are required on all street and other front frontages. a.Eave Depth. Eaves must have a depth of at least 14 inches. Eave depth is measured from the building facade to the outside edge of the eave. b.Eave Thickness. Eaves must be a minimum of 6 inches thick. Eave thickness is measured at the outside edge of the eave, from the bottom of the eave to the top of the eave. (3)Interrupting Vertical Walls. Vertical walls may interrupt the flat roof and extend above the top of the eave with no discernible roof type. a.No more than one-third or 30 feet, whichever is less, of any front facade may consist of an interrupting vertical wall. b.Vertical walls shall extend no more than 8 feet above the top of the eave. (4)Occupied Building Space. Occupied building space must not be incorporated behind this roof type, including the flat roof and vertical wall. See 102-16170 for definition of occupied building space. (5)Rooftop Appurtenances. With the exception of solar panels, rooftop appurtenances may not be located on the flat portion of this roof type. Any rooftop appurtenances may be located behind the interrupting vertical wall with no visibility from the sidewalk across the street or may be located within a tower per 102-720 (f). Figure 7-B. Example of a Flat Roof type RoofRoof Eave Eave DepthDepth Eave Eave ThicknessThickness Vertical Vertical Wall PlaneWall Plane upper floorupper floor 7-3CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-720 Roof Types 102-720 (e) PITCHED ROOF TYPE This roof type is a sloped or pitched roof, where the slope occurs on all street and other front facades. Slope is measured with the vertical rise divided by the horizontal span or run. See Figure 7-C Examples of a Pitched Roofs. (1)Pitch Measure. The roof may not be sloped less than a 4:12 (rise:run) or more than 14:12. Slopes less than 4:12 are permitted to occur on second story or higher roofs. (2)Configurations. a.Hipped, gabled, and a combination of hips and gables with or without dormers are allowed. When the ridge line runs parallel to any street or other front frontage, one of the following must occur: 1.A gabled end or perpendicular ridge line must occur at least every 100 feet of roof; or 2.One dormer must be provided for every 15 feet of ridge line on any street or front frontage with at least one dormer per frontage. 3.Occupied building space within the roof is allowed and counts as a half or full story. See 102-16210 definition of half story and any half story limitations per the building type regulations. See 102-16170 for definition of occupied building space. b.Butterfly (or inverted gable or V-shaped roof) and shed roofs are not allowed, except per the following: 1.The butterfly or shed roof must not exceed 8 feet in total height, inclusive of overhang. 2.The portion of the building footprint below the butterfly roof may not be greater than 5,000 square feet. 3.Occupied building space within the roof is allowed and counts as a half or full story. See 102-16210 definition of half story and any half story limitations per the building type regulations. See 102-16170 for definition of occupied building space. c.Mansard roofs are not allowed. Gambrel roofs are allowed, provided the following are met: 1.The main ridge line of the gambrel roof must be perpendicular to the front street. 2.Gambrel roofs with the ridge parallel to a side street must include one dormer for every 15 feet of ridge line with at least one dormer per frontage. Figure 7-C. Examples of Pitched Roof type Low Pitched Roof Roof type (Hip Roof) upper floor Pitched Roof type (Gable Roof) upper floor upper floor Parallel Pitched Roof Roof SlopeSlope Roof Roof HeightHeight Roof Roof HeightHeight Roof Roof HeightHeight Roof Roof SlopeSlope Roof Roof SlopeSlope Figure 7-D. Example of a Tower Tower WidthTower Width Tower Tower WidthWidth Tower Tower HeightHeight Allowable Allowable Roof typeRoof type 7-4 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-720 Roof Types 3.The steepest portion of the roof must be no greater than the tallest permitted height of one upper story. 4.Occupied building space is required beneath the gambrel roof and counts as a half or full story, based upon the percentage of footprint allowed for a half story within the building type regulations. See 102-16210 definition of half story and any half story limitations per the building type regulations. See 102-16170 for definition of occupied building space. (3)Maximum Roof Height. Roofs without occupied building space and/or dormers must have a maximum height on front and non-front frontage facades equal to no more than 1.5 times the upper story floor to floor height utilized on the building. (4)Rooftop Appurtenances. With the exception of solar panels, antennae, and wind turbines, any rooftop appurtenances must be recessed within the pitched roof with no visibility on any street elevation drawing. See 102-760 for additional regulations of mechanical equipment. 102-720 (f) TOWERS A tower is a vertical element that must be used with other roof types. See Figure 7-D Example of a tower. (1)Degree of Enclosure. A street facade tower must be fully enclosed. Any interior building tower may be partially or fully enclosed. A fully open structure, such as a rooftop gazebo is not a tower. (2)Quantity. Unless otherwise defined in the building type regulations, the following is allowed: a.Street Facade Towers. A maximum of 2 towers located within 15 feet of any street facade is permitted on any building. Street facade towers enhance the facade design. b.Interior Building Towers. Two additional towers are permitted provided the towers are located a minimum of 30 feet from any street facade. Interior towers are typically functional, providing housing for utilities or access to the roof. (3)Tower Height a.Maximum height, measured from the top of the uppermost floor of the building to the top of the tower shaft, not including the tower roof, is the equivalent of the height of one upper floor of the building to which the tower is applied. b.A tower allows for up to one additional story of height within the tower footprint to any building type where permitted. (4)Tower Footprint a.A tower footprint may be polygonal (simple, e.g. hexagonal or octagonal), rectalinear, or cylindrical in plan. b.The maximum width in any direction of the footprint of any tower is 1/3 the width of any street or front facade or 30 feet, whichever is less. (5)Tower Spacing. Street facade towers, within 15 feet of any street facade, must be spaced a minimum of 120 feet from other street facade towers. Interior building towers must be located a minimum of 60 feet from any other tower. (6)Transparency. Towers that meet the minimum floor- to-floor to height of the building type and are located within 30 feet of a street facade shall meet the minimum front street facade transparency requirements of an upper story of the building type to which the tower is applied. (7)Horizontal Shadow lines. If the tower extends the building up to a 5th or higher story, a shadow line is required between the 4th and 5th stories on any tower. Shadow lines required by the roof type used on the tower also apply. (8)Occupied Building Space. Towers may be occupied by the same uses allowed in upper stories of the building type to which it is applied. See 102-16170 for definition of occupied building space. (9)Rooftop Appurtenances. No rooftop appurtenances are permitted on tower roofs. Roof appurtenances may be housed within a tower. (10)Tower Roof. The tower may be roofed by the parapet, pitched, or flat roof types. 7-5CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-720 Roof Types 102-730 Entrance Types 102-730 (a) APPLICABILITY The following entrance type regulations apply to buildings in the mixed-use and public-institutional zones. The facade regulations for each building type regulate which entrance types are allowed on the building types. See Article 2 and Article 3 for building types. 102-730 (b) STOREFRONT ENTRANCE TYPE (1)Recessed Entrance. Where the sidewalk outside the storefront is less than 7 feet in width, measured perpendicular to the facade, entrances must be recessed as follows: a.The door must be recessed a minimum of 3 feet and a maximum of 8 feet deep, measured from the main building facade, and may exceed the maximum setback regulation. b.The maximum width of the recess is 10 feet. (2)Transparency. A minimum amount of ground story storefront glass is required per the building type regulations. a.The storefront glass must turn the corner of any recessed entry as shown in Figure 7-E. b.Transom windows above doors are encouraged. Transom windows are encouraged to extend along all storefront windows. (3)Clear Windows. Windows must be unobstructed during the daytime and evening hours. Displays inside the building, viewable from outside the window, may be included, but the area on the other side of the window display must be occupied building space with daylight extending into the space. See 102-10100 for window signs. (4)Bulkhead. Where a bulkhead is incorporated, the maximum height is 24 inches. A bulkhead is the lower set of panels or low wall upon which the storefront windows rest. See Figure 7-E. The bulkhead may be constructed of wood, metal, stained concrete, spandrel glass, or masonry. Concrete masonry units may not be exposed. 102-730 (c) STOOP ENTRANCE TYPE A stoop is a small, open platform that may include a canopy or roof cantilevered off the building and may or may not be elevated above the sidewalk. (1)Stoop Size. Stoops must be a minimum of 4 feet wide and 3 feet deep. BulkheadBulkhead Storefront Storefront GlassGlass Transom Transom WindowWindow Sign Sign BandBand Horizontal Horizontal Shadow Line per Shadow Line per building typebuilding type Recessed EntryRecessed Entry Windows Windows extending into extending into recessrecess Figure 7-E. Example of a Storefront Entrance Figure 7-F. Example of Elevated Storefront street sidewalkstreet sidewalk StorefrontStorefrontBasementBasementEntryEntry Platform Level SidewalkPlatform Level Sidewalk Landscape Area or Landscape Area or Visible BasementVisible Basement ramp down to grade ramp down to grade 7-6 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-730 Entrance Types (2)Ramps. Where feasible, ramps should be incorporated at the principal building entrance and designed as an integrated part of the stoop, with rails matching any provided on steps. 102-730 (d) PORCH ENTRANCE TYPE A porch is a raised, roofed platform that may or may not be enclosed on all sides and may or may not be elevated above the sidewalk. (1)Transparency. If a porch is enclosed, refer to the building type for minimum transparency requirements. (2)Porch Size. The porch shall be a minimum of 5 feet deep and 8 feet wide. (3)Height. Porch may be 2 stories to provide a balcony on the second floor. (4)Ramps. Where feasible, ramps should be incorporated at the principal building entrance and designed as an integrated part of the stoop, with rails matching any provided on steps. Visible BasementVisible Basement Figure 7-G. Example of Stoop Entrance Figure 7-H. Example of Porch Entrance Ramp to Ramp to StoopStoop Raised, Raised, Uncovered StoopUncovered Stoop 7-7CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-730 Entrance Types 102-740 Facade Materials 102-740 (a) APPLICABILITY All facades on all buildings in any zone except N zones must meet the regulations for facade materials in this section. 102-740 (b) MAJOR STREET FACADE MATERIALS Major facade materials are intended to serve as the primary surface material of street facades and other highly visible front facades. (1)Street and Other Front Facades. Allowed major facade materials, listed in Table 7-1, must be applied to a minimum of 65% of all street or other front facades, not including window and door areas. Other front facades include those facing civic spaces, as defined in 102-350 (e). (2)Simplicity of Facade Materials. A single major facade material must be used for each building facade segment, 60-foot or larger. See Figure 7-I. (3)Exception. For IX-S zone, street facades located more than 100 feet from the street are exempt from the major facade material requirements. (4)Side and Rear Facades. When side yards between two buildings are a total of 5 or more feet in width, major materials must be applied along that side facade from the front of the building a distance equal to the width of the side yard, as measured perpendicularly between the two side facades. (5)Original Facade Materials. Where brick or stone is an existing building's original facade material, the following applies: a.The original brick or stone may be maintained if in good condition or repaired, or the brick or stone may be replaced by new brick or stone. b.A different major material may not be installed over the original brick or stone. 102-740 (c) MINOR STREET FACADE MATERIALS (1)Maximum Minor Materials for Street Facades. A maximum of 35% of each street or other front facade surface, not including window and door areas, may be composed of minor facade materials per Table 7-2. Other front facades include those facing civic spaces, as defined in 102-350 (e). (2)Accents and Details. Additional materials are allowed for trim, accents, and details per Table 7-4, not included in the maximum surface area. 102-740 (d) SIDE & REAR FACADE MATERIALS (1)Rail and Trail Facades. Interior side and rear (non- street) facades along any rail line and along any trail, such as the Minnesota River Bluffs Trail, must be faced in a major facade material, a minor facade material (unless Figure 7-I. Major vs. Minor Materials Major Facade Major Facade MaterialMaterial Major Facade MaterialMajor Facade Material Minor Facade Minor Facade MaterialMaterial Minor Facade Minor Facade MaterialMaterial Minor Facade MaterialMinor Facade Material Accent Material Accent Material (column)(column) Minor Facade MaterialMinor Facade Material Building Segment (must turn corner)Building Segment (must turn corner)Building Segment Building Segment Min. 60-ft.Min. 60-ft.Min. 60-ft.Min. 60-ft.Min. 60-ft.Min. 60-ft. 7-8 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials otherwise noted in Table 7-3), or a material as allowed in Table 7-3. (2)All Other Side and Rear Facades. All interior side and rear (non-street) facades not located on a rail or trail line must be faced in a major facade material, a minor facade material (unless otherwise noted in Table 7-3), or a material as allowed in Table 7-3. 102-740 (e) PITCHED ROOF MATERIALS Allowed pitched roof materials include dimensional asphalt composite shingles, wood shingles and shakes, metal tiles or standing seam, slate, ceramic tile, engineered wood or slate. 102-740 (f) APPROPRIATE GRADE OF MATERIALS All doors, windows, and hardware must be of commercial grade quality with the exception of those on Row and House buildings. 102-740 (g) MATERIALS INSTALLATION The following materials installation requirements are intended to advance the quality of construction, durability, and aesthetics of new buildings, specifically related to application and detailing of facade materials. (1)Changes in Facade Materials. Changes in facade materials, whether major materials or minor materials, should occur mainly at concave corners or changes in facade planes. (2)Materials Hierarchy. A hierarchy of materials must be maintained on the building facade, where "heavier", articulated unit materials (brick, concrete masonry units, stone) are located at the base of the facade and "lighter", constant surface materials with fewer seams (stucco, panels) are located above those on the facade. (3)Shadow Lines on Surfaces. Shadow lines must delineate changes in materials with solid materials of a thickness that is greater than 1.5 inches, such as cast stone, masonry, or stone. For example, cast stone elements or brick may be offset to create a shadow. 7-9CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials Table 7-1. Allowed Major Facade Materials BUILDING TYPES & ZONES MAJOR FACADE MATERIAL (alphabetical) STOREFRONT, GENERAL BUILDINGS COMMERCIAL HOUSE, ROW BUILDING, TRADITIONAL HOUSE WORKSHOP- WAREHOUSE CIVIC BUILDING MX-D, MX-N, RX-D, RX-N, NX2 MX-TOD, RX-TOD, MX-S IX-TOD, IX-S MX-N, RX-N, NX1, NX2 IX-TOD, IX-S, I-TOD ALL AA Brick full dimensional, economy, unit, face brick 44 44 44 44 44 44 BB Concrete Masonry Units architectural, minimum 3” depth, “artisan stone” look, varied sizes, (Eschelon Masonry or approved equal), “stone” face, “hewn stone”, rock cut –44 44 –44 44 CC Fiber Cement Board panels, finished lap siding or shingles – – – 44 –44 DD Glass curtain wall – – 44 –44 44 EE Metal, Architectural architectural panel, cladding system (steel, titanium, zinc) – – 44 –44 44 FF Stone natural, units 44 44 44 44 44 44 Stucco cement-based, 2-3 layer hard coat –44 44 –44 44 GG Vinyl & PVC Siding minimum �040 in� thick – – – 44 – – HH Wood or Composite Wood painted, stained, charred, or treated lap siding, shingles, board & batten, rainscreen – – – 44 – – AA BB BB CCAA 7-10 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials Table 7-2. Allowed Street Facade Minor Materials All major facade materials allowed on the building type in the zone per Table 7-1 may be used for minor facade materials, unless otherwise listed as prohibited� MINOR FACADE MATERIAL (alphabetical) ALLOWED ON BUILDING TYPES OTHER LIMITATIONS MAXIMUM AMOUNT ON STREET & OTHER FRONT FACADES Concrete Surfaces finished, stained, painted, treated All Below ground floor only 15% BB Concrete Masonry Units architectural, minimum 3” depth, “artisan stone” look, varied sizes, (Eschelon Masonry or approved equal), “stone” face, “hewn stone”, rock cut All –35% JJ Concrete Masonry Units minimum 3” depth, split-faced, burnished/ground face, glazed, or honed Workshop-Warehouse –35% CC Fiber Cement Board finished panels All Major material is required at grade up to 2 feet and adjacent to entrances 35% DD Glass curtain wall All except Traditional and Commercial House –35% EE Metal Architectural architectural panel, cladding system (steel, titanium, zinc) All, except buildings in MX- D, RX-D and all Commercial House, Traditional House Major material is required at grade up to 2 feet and adjacent to entrances 35% LL Stucco synthetic or with elastomeric finishes All Only 3rd or higher stories 35% Stucco cement-based, 2-3 layer hard coat All –35% Terracotta or Ceramic tiles or panels All –35% HH Wood painted, stained, treated, natural, or aged lap siding, shingles, board & batten All –35% II Wood, Composite lap siding, shingles, board & batten, rainscreen system All –35% EE EE CC DD 7-11CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials Table 7-3. Allowed Non-Street Facade Materials All allowed major facade materials and minor facade materials may be used on 100% of non-street facade, unless otherwise indicated below or unless listed as prohibited in Table 7-5� MINOR FACADE MATERIAL (alphabetical) ALLOWED ON BUILDING TYPES OTHER LIMITATIONS MAXIMUM AMOUNT ON NON-STREET FACADES MAXIMUM AMOUNT ON RAIL & TRAIL FACADES Brick thin, veneer All –100% 100% PP Concrete Surfaces unfinished , untreated, unstained, unpainted General and Workshop- Warehouse buildings in IX and I zones only –100% 35% Concrete Surfaces finished, stained, painted, treated All –100% 35% II Concrete Masonry Units minimum 3” depth, split-faced, burnished/ground face, glazed, or honed All except Traditional and Commercial House, Row –100% 100% KK Glass Block clear or patterned units without color All –35%15% LL Metal, Aluminum Composite aluminum composite materials (ACM) or panels (ACP) All except Traditional and Commercial House Only 3rd or higher stories 35% 35% Metal, Corrugated, Other ribbed, corrugated, sheet Workshop-Warehouse –100% 100% Stucco synthetic or with elastomeric finishes All Only 3rd or higher stories 35% 35% 4 | ARCHITECTURAL MASONR Y P R O D U C T C A T A L O G PHOTO Shippensburg University Dorm Shippensburg, PA Colors: A-18 (not shown) & NM-173 IDEAL FOR • Interior & exterior facades • Adding appeal & uniform finish • Accent band • Natural beauty due to aggregates JJ KK LL LL FF HH GG II 7-12 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials MM OO NN PP QQ RR Table 7-4. Allowed Detail & Accent Materials All allowed major and minor facade materials may be used for details, trim, and accents� MM Concrete Details precast stone ornamentation, lintels, sills, banding, columns, beams Fiber Cement Details trim, soffits NN Metal Details trim, ornamentation, lintels, beams, columns Wood and Wood Composite Details painted/treated trim, soffits, other approved details OO Vinyl Details limited to soffits, window trim; minimum �04 inches thick Table 7-5. Prohibited Materials Fiberglass and Acrylic Panels all QQ Plastic Panels all, including high-density polyethylene and polycarbonate panels RR Stucco Moldings or Synthetic Stucco Moldings trim, sills, cornices, banding, columns, pilasters or other 3 dimensional details Wood Unfinished, untreated plywood siding or panels 7-13CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-740 Facade Materials 102-750 Facade Elements 102-750 (a) APPLICABILITY The facade element regulations in this section, 102-750, apply to all buildings in any zone except N zones. 102-750 (b) WINDOWS Windows on all street and other front facades of all buildings shall be constructed consistent with the following requirements: (1)Amount. Each building must meet the transparency requirements per the building regulations. See Article 3. (2)Recessed. All windows, with the exception of ground story storefront systems and glass curtain wall systems, shall be recessed with the glass a minimum of 2 inches from the facade surface material or adjacent trim. (3)Vertically Oriented. A minimum of 70% of street facade windows must be vertically oriented. An abutting series of individually vertically oriented windows creating a horizontally oriented bank of windows is acceptable. (4)Visibility Through Glass. Reflective glass and glass block are prohibited on street and other front facades. Windows shall meet the transmittance and reflectance factors established in the transparency definition (see 102-1620 (m)). (5)Operable Windows. A minimum of 70% of all street facade upper story windows on all buildings, except the Workshop-Warehouse, must be operable. Ground story storefront glass and glass curtain wall systems are not required to be operable. (6)Expressed Lintels. For masonry construction, the expression of lintels must be included above all windows and doors by a change in brick coursing or by a separate detail or element. See Figure 7-J for illustrations of expressed lintels. (7)Glass Overhead Doors. Glass overhead doors utilized for patio access, open air dining, or display and not utilized for vehicular access, may be used for storefronts or other window requirements on any building type, provided all other regulations are met, and health department licensing is obtained as required. 102-750 (c) AWNINGS & CANOPIES Removable awnings and canopies attached to buildings shall be constructed consistent with the requirements of this section. See Figure 7-K for examples of awnings. (1)Material. All awnings and canopies shall be canvas or metal. Plastic awnings are prohibited. Figure 7-J. Vertically Oriented Windows with Expressed Lintels Metal Awning Canvas Awning Figure 7-K. Examples of Awnings 7-14 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements (2)Lighting. Backlighting is allowed only on metal awnings. (3)Structures. Frames must be metal and wall mounted. Support poles from the ground are prohibited except where the awning is over 8 feet in depth and utilized for outdoor eating areas or entrances. (4)Canopies & Light Shelves. Permanent canopies, projections, or overhangs used as architectural features, light shelves, or shading devices are allowed and not intended to be regulated by this subsection 102-750 (c). (5)Clearance. All portions of any awning or canopy shall provide at least 8 feet of clearance over any walkway and 15 feet of clearance over vehicular areas. (6)Signs. Refer to Article 10 for signs on awnings and canopies. 102-750 (d) BALCONIES Balconies on street facades, facades of courtyard open to the street or civic space, and facades on civic space shall be consistent with the requirements of this subsection. See Figure 7-L for examples of balconies. (1)Definition. For the purpose of this subsection, balconies shall include any roofed or unroofed platform that projects from the wall of a building above grade and is enclosed only by a parapet or railing. This definition does not include false balconies, juliet balconies, or balconettes. (2)Balconettes. Sometimes referred to as juliet balconies, balconettes are false balconies consisting of a rail and door, either without an outdoor platform or with an outdoor platform less than 18 inches in depth. Balconettes are allowed and do not count towards the maximum permitted amount of balcony on a street facade. (3)Size. Balconies must be a minimum of 4 feet deep and 5 feet wide. (4)Facade Coverage. A maximum of 35 percent of street facades, calculated separately for each facade, may be covered by balconies. The balcony area is calculated by drawing a rectangle on the facade elevation around the following: the platform or floor of the balcony; any rails, walls, columns or indentations; and any ceiling, roof, or upper balcony. (5)Integrated Design. Balconies are intended to be integrated with the design of the facade, avoiding tacking the balconies onto the facade after the elevation has been designed. Balconies: Covers More than 35 Percent of Facade Balconies: Extending Off Facade Balconies Appropriately Attached to or Incorporated into Facade. NOT ALLOWED Figure 7-L. Examples of Balconies NOT ALLOWED 7-15CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements a. A minimum of 50 percent of the perimeter of each balcony must abut an exterior wall of the building, partially enclosing the balcony. b. The balcony support structure must be integrated with the building facade; separate columns or posts supporting any balcony from the ground are not allowed. (6) Platform. The balcony platform must be at least 3 inches thick and any underside of a balcony that is visible from any street or public way shall be finished. (7) Maximum Setback. When the balcony is located within the minimum and maximum setback area, the portion of the facade behind the balcony is exempt from meeting the maximum setback requirement. 102-750 (e) SHUTTERS When shutters, whether functional or not, are utilized on a street or other front facade of any building type except a House building type, the shutters shall meet the following requirements. See Figure 7-N. (1) Size. All shutters must be sized for the windows, so that, if the shutters were to be closed, they would not be too small for complete coverage of the window. (2) Materials. Shutters must be wood, metal, or fiber cement. Other synthetic and engineered woods may be approved provided that the applicant submits a sample and examples of high quality, local installations of the material. 102-750 (f) SECURITY GRILLS & BARS (1) Exterior bars and security grills are prohibited on any street facade opening. (2) Security grills must be fully retractable and completely located within the interior of the building. When retracted, the grills must not be visible from the exterior of the building. 102-750 (g) PRINCIPAL ENTRYWAY See Figure 7-M for examples of defined principal entryways. Principal entrances to all buildings or units, except storefronts, must be clearly delineated through one or more of the following design features: (1) Roof or Canopy. The entryway is covered by a roof or canopy differentiating it from the overall building roof type. (2) Porch. The entryway is through a porch. (3) Sidelights and Transom. Sidelights or transom windows are included around the entryway.Figure 7-M. Examples of Defined Principal Entryways Inappropriately Scaled Shutters.NOT PERMITTED Figure 7-N. Examples of Shutters 7-16 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements (4) Extended Articulation. The entryway is included in a separate bay of the building that extends up at least 2 stories. 102-750 (h) ARCADE DESIGN The following requirements apply to arcades. An arcade is a covered pedestrian walkway within the recess of a ground story. See Figure 7-O. (1) Depth. An open-air public walkway may be recessed from the principal facade of the building a minimum of 8 feet and a maximum of 16 feet. (2) Height. The height of the interior space of the arcade, measured floor to ceiling, must not exceed 16 feet. (3) Maximum Setback. When the arcade is utilized, the outside face of the arcade shall be considered the front facade, located within the required minimum and maximum setback area. (4) Column Spacing. Columns must be spaced between 10 feet and 12 feet on center. (5) Column Width. Columns must be a minimum of 1.5 feet 6 inches and a maximum 2 foot 6 inches in width. (6) Arcade Openings. Openings must not be flush with interior arcade ceiling and may be arched or straight. (7) Horizontal Facade Division. A horizontal shadow line shall define the ground story facade from the upper stories. (8) Visible Basement. A visible basement is not allowed. 102-750 (i) GROUND STORY AT SLOPING FACADES Grade transitions on any building along a significantly slope sidewalk or street should be designed to minimize blank walls and maximize pedestrian-scale frontages between waist and eye level. See Figure 7-P for examples of positive facades along slopes. (1) Storefronts. The following regulations apply to storefront facades along sloping streets: a. The interior floor level must step to match the exterior grade within 3 feet. b. Knee wall and retaining walls must not exceed 30 inches in height except a maximum 9-foot section of length may be up to 48 inches in height. c. If grade change is more than 9 feet along a single block face, the following applies: 1. Entrance requirements may be increased to one entrance per 90 feet of building frontage. Figure 7-O.  Example of Arcade. sidewalksidewalk Arcade OpeningArcade Opening Recessed or Recessed or Interior FaceInterior Face Column Column WidthWidth Shadow lineShadow line BaseBase Figure 7-P.  Examples of Ground Story along Slopes. 7-17CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements 2. Entrances adjacent to the street must be within 3 feet of the elevation of the adjacent sidewalk. (2) Non-Storefronts. The following regulations apply to all non-storefront facades along sloping streets: a. Grade transitions at the building along the sidewalk shall be designed to minimize blank walls. Multiple front entrances along the street should activate each segment of building section at each grade. b. The interior floor level must step to match the changes in exterior grade within a 3-foot range. c. Changes can be accommodated by terraced planters and retaining walls at the lowest heights practicable. Retaining walls shall not exceed 30 inches in height except along a maximum 8-foot section of frontage. d. When the elevation of the first floor is more than 3 feet above grade, the elevation is considered a visible basement and windows must be provided into the basement or lower floor elevation. 102-750 (j) BUILDING VARIETY See Figure 7-Q for examples of building facade variety with intent of providing interest and variety along street and open space frontages. (1) MX Zones. Buildings must treat that frontage in segments of 50 feet or less with the building variety standards in 102-750 (j)(3), below. (2) RX, IX, and NX Zones. For buildings 90 feet in length or greater, as measured along any street or front facade, must treat that frontage in segments of 50 feet or less with the building variety standards in 102-750 (j)(3), below. (3) Standards. Each facade segment must vary by at least 2 of the following: a. The type of dominant facade material or by color, scale, or orientation of that material; b. The proportion of recesses and projections within the minimum and maximum setback area; c. The location of the entrance and window placement, unless storefronts are utilized; d. Roof type, plane, or material, unless otherwise stated in the building requirements; e. Building height. 102-750 (k) ARTICULATION OF STORIES Stories must be articulated on street and other front facades. Figure 7-Q.  Examples of Building Articulation Figure 7-R.  Example of a Terminated Vista. 7-18 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements (1) Fenestration. Fenestration or window placement on street facades must be organized by stories per the building type facade transparency regulations. (2) Shadow Lines. Horizontal shadow lines and lintels over openings may be used to delineate stories with minimum shadow lines required per building type. (3) Mezzanines. Mezzanines that fall within the range of floor to floor heights of the building type shall be articulated on the facade and require separate calculation for transparency per 102-1620 (m) (7) Tall Stories. (4) Taller Spaces. Spaces exceeding the allowable floor to floor heights of the building type shall be articulated as multiple stories on the street facade. 102-750 (l) VISTAS Views down streets must be considered when locating open space, parking, and buildings on sites and designing building facades. Figure 7-R. (1) Rears of Buildings. Rears of buildings must not be visible at the termination of a street vista. (2) Parking. Parking structures and surface parking lots are not permitted at the termination of a street vista. (3) Building Design. When a street terminates at a parcel, the facade of a building, whether facing a front street or not, must terminate the view and the building must incorporate one of the following treatments to terminate the view: a tower, a bay, or a courtyard. That portion of the facade shall be treated as a front facade. 102-750 (m) GARAGE DOORS The following requirements apply to garage doors included on any street facade. (1) Location. Allowed locations for garage doors on street and non-street facades are regulated by the building type regulations. (2) Recessed from Facades. Garage doors located on street facades must be recessed a minimum of 5 feet from the dominant facade of the principal building facing the same street. (3) Design. Garage doors facing a street or visible from a street must meet the following: a. The doors must be clad with materials consistent with the design of the building. b. Upgraded architectural doors or carriage-style doors are required on all Row buildings. 102-750 (n) PARKING STRUCTURE FACADES Parking structure facades visible from any street or abutting any pedestrianway or open space shall meet the following standards. See Figure 7-R for one illustration of a parking structure facade. (1) Materials. Major and minor material requirements, per 102-740, above, shall be met on all street and other front facades. An additional permitted minor material is stained, finished concrete. (2) Ramps and Slopes. Ramps and slopes shall not be located on any front or street facades. (3) Vertical Divisions. Vertical divisions extending the full height of the structure are required every 30 feet to deemphasize the horizontal decks. Divisions shall be a minimum of 2 feet in width with a minimum projection of 2 inches. (4) Blank Wall Limitations. No rectangular area greater than 30 percent of any story’s facade, as measured from Entry Tower Cap Vehicular Entrance Vertical Divisions Blank Wall Limitations and No Ramps or Slopes Figure 7-S. One Example of a Parking Structure 7-19CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-750 Facade Elements floor to floor, and no horizontal segment of a story’s facade greater than 15 feet in width may be solid wall without an opening. (5) Entry Tower. A pedestrian entrance directly into the parking structure from the street is required to be separate from the vehicular entrance and directly accessed from the sidewalk. The pedestrian entrance must meet the principal entryway regulations in 102-750 (g). Stairwells must be located inside a tower per 102- 720 (f) with windows at a transparency rate of 65%. (6) Cap. The top story of the parking structure shall include a parapet or other roof type along the public way facades. Refer to roof types defined in 102-720. (7) Vehicular Entrances. Driveways shall be no wider than 22 feet and the entrance and exit should be split by a median. Access shall be located on a non-front street, unless the lot does not abut a non-front street. No more than 2 access points shall be located on any one street, totaling no more than 24 feet of drives crossing sidewalk. 102-760 Utility Equipment Mechanical and utility equipment and appurtenances are necessary for any building design, but can have a negative visual impact and detract from the quality of the design of a building. The purpose of the regulations of this section, 102-760, is to ensure that the visual impact of mechanical equipment and appurtenances is minimized. 102-760 (a) "MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT" DEFINED When the following regulations refer to "mechanical equipment", any mechanical equipment or utility appurtenance, such as but not limited to HVAC systems, boilers, condensers, transformers, vents, meters, ducts, are being referenced, except the following: (1) Solar and wind energy systems are allowed, subject to 102-6140 in accessory structure regulations. (2) Rainwater cisterns are allowed. 102-760 (b) MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT IN BUILDING Mechanical equipment shall be located within the building, unless the applicant demonstrates that locating the equipment within the building would conflict with the equipment’s function. 102-760 (c) ROOFTOP MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT Any rooftop mechanical equipment, such as but not limited to vents, ducts, condensers, and ventilators,and not including solar panels or wind turbines, shall be located consistent with one of the following methods: (1) Incorporate equipment into the roof design consistent with the applicable standards of roof types in 102-720. (2) Set the equipment back a minimum of 10 feet from any street or public way facade. (3) To the extent practicable, all rooftop mechanical shall be painted to blend with the structural roof and limit its visibility. 102-760 (d) MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT ON STREET FACADES Mechanical equipment and utility appurtenances shall not be located on a street facade unless the applicant demonstrates that locating the equipment in a different location would conflict with the equipment’s function. Any equipment or appurtenance approved on a facade shall be located consistent with the following standards: (1) Street Facade. The mechanical equipment may be located on a street facade only if the following requirements are met: a. The equipment is located on a surface perpendicular to the adjacent street and not parallel to the adjacent 7-20 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-760 Utility Equipment street, unless there is no other option, provided all other requirements of this subsection, 102-760 (d), are met. b. The equipment extends from the facade surface no more than 3 inches; and c. The equipment is screened from the sidewalk by landscape, railings, other facade walls, or other designs. (2) Air Vents or Grills. Air vents and grills may be successfully incorporated into storefront window systems, provided the transparency requirements are met by the actual windows in the system. (3) Alignment. Multiple pieces of mechanical equipment must be organized on the facade in a regular pattern and aligned. Compliance with this standard must be illustrated on the drawing elevations submitted as part of the application. (4) Material Coordination. To the extent practicable, facade-mounted mechanical appurtenances shall be located on a material that limits their visibility. For example, dark colored vents will be more visible on light colored fiber cement panels than a textured, darker surface such as brick. 102-760 (e) MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT ON OTHER HORIZONTAL SURFACES Mechanical equipment, such as electrical transformers and air conditioners, located on the ground, decks, or horizontal surfaces other than the roof shall be located consistent with the following standards: (1) No Encroachment. Mechanical equipment shall not extend into any right-of-way or easement, unless otherwise approved by the City. (2) Allowed Yard Location. See 102-16270 for definition of yards. a. Front Street Yard. Mechanical equipment and appurtenances shall not be located in the front street yard. b. Non-Front Street Yard. Mechanical equipment may be approved in the non-front street yard, provided the equipment is screened from the street per the following regulations. c. Rear and Side Yard. Mechanical equipment may be located in any rear or side yard. (3) Screening from streets, open spaces, or civic spaces. All equipment must be screened from view from any streets, open space, or civic space per the following: a. Walls for screening must be consistent with the building design, colors, and materials, faced with an allowed major facade material. b. Where landscaping only is employed, the following must be met: 1. Where landscaping only is employed, the utility must be located in a larger landscape area and the landscape screen must be designed as part of the large planting bed design. 2. A single row of evergreen shrubs shall fully screen the equipment within 1 year of installation. 3. The zoning administrator may require additional landscape materials. (4) Street Frontage or Front Yard Location. Equipment located in a street yard or other front yard may approved only if all of the following are met: a. The applicant demonstrates that the equipment cannot be located in a rear yard, street side yard, or in a side yard. b. Equipment may be located in a front street yard only if the applicant demonstrates that the equipment cannot be located in a non-front street yard. c. No other utility cabinets, boxes, or other appurtenances are within 200 feet along the same side of the street as the proposed utility appurtenance. d. The appurtenance is located a minimum of 35 feet from a street intersection, measured from the intersection of the curb line, and does not impact the sight vision clearance at intersections. e. The appurtenance is fully screened in a manner that is consistent with the building design, colors, and materials and of a height that is the minimum to adequately screen the appurtenance and that does not prevent the facade from fulfilling any transparency requirements. See Figure 5.03(8) for examples of poorly located, unscreened equipment on front streets. 7-21CITY OF HOPKINS MNEffective July 28, 2022 Article 7 Building Design 102-760 Utility Equipment Figure 7-T.  Utility Appurtenances located on Facades Figure 7-U.  Rooftop Utilities Screened from the Public Way by a Parapet Figure 7-V.  Examples of Poorly Located Utility Appurtenances on Primary Streets: NOT PERMITTED Utility vents Utility vents aligned and aligned and colored to colored to match facade match facade surfacesurface Hotel room Hotel room vents organized vents organized and integrated and integrated into the facade into the facade designdesign Example of Example of poorly located poorly located vents on vents on contrasting contrasting materialmaterial Example of vents Example of vents located as part of located as part of storefront window storefront window systemsystem Utility vents Utility vents colored to colored to match facade match facade surfacesurface 7-22 Development CodeCITY OF HOPKINS MN Article 7 Building Design 102-760 Utility Equipment